I care most about the Internal Rate of Return (helps me determine how long to hold a property), the cash on cash return (helps me decide why this investment vs other options, and it also takes into consideration appreciation of the property!)

The first one will likely determine how quickly that second purchase can be made. 

There are other ways to determine rental amounts like researching in zillow and/or rentometer, which I typically reference.

The property feels like you are in the jungle yet is on a paved road with high speed fiber optic internet and within walking distance of great restaurants that are owned and operated by entrepreneurs from around the world.

I want to share with others that I called the Attorney for D32 today and she stated that the storms knocked out the internet and the offices but it was not a reason for any delay on the return of deposits. 

At closing, the buyer and their lender determine whether the credit will reduce down payment, closing costs, or as a credit.5.

I don't know enough about your rentals to determine quality, location, or layout, but I suspect my numbers are pretty close.However, your utilities are pretty expensive in the winter.

I don't doubt that guys like me and you will succeed over a long enough time frame due to drive, ability to go do it, and determination, but the timeline shifts drastically due to the momentum killing L's we took early in our career.This is why it's hard to compare yourselves to the real estate winners of the past decade. 

Yes, when there are multiple adult occupants, you would typically combine their gross incomes to determine if they meet the income criteria.

Determine if the area can support new construction.