It might not be 100% accurate but it'll at least give you some directional data to use. 

.), and you've made your House Rules clear, then don't sweat the small stuff.By that, I mean- you'll have guests who have 5-star ratings but can still leave a mess or damage (other owners didn't report accurately or it was complicated) but you have recourse via photo evidence (your cleaners, etc.) to ask for reimbursement (or use something like AirCover, etc.).

@Silas Melson, I agree with @Bruce Woodruff that a price per square foot approach is likely to be the least accurate and least useful.

Unfortunately, the previous owner (who was also a licensed agent) didn’t accurately represent the tenant situation.

They're more likely to have clean and accurate financials and you're less likely to be in competition with cash buyers.

I'm about to start a team of callers on these lists, but I don't want to waste their time or my time with these dead leads.I'm thinking of charging back the expense with my credit card company because I'm pretty disappointed.Does anyone have any solutions they'd recommend for getting accurate property owner phone numbers?

Stats are all over the place.I will say that I think ours are more accurate due to the limited number of STRs in our area.

I truly appreciate your effort to ensure that the information on this forum is accurate and helpful for everyone.

I've had a free trial of property radar before, and I was impressed, but how do we know the data is accurate and current for any of these platforms?

It’s always a good idea to consult a local real estate attorney and title company for more accurate estimates in your area.