We also just purchased a house in Oliver, WI that we plan to run as a short-term rental.

I currently live in Butte, Mt but plan on moving to Phoenix, Az for 6 months out of the year.

It sounds like you've got a solid foundation and a great game plan, especially with your background in North Padre and passion for fishing, which could really set your STR apart.

They are billed as "a scientific approach to single-family rentals" and use "institutional grade property management," which usually means they are a tech company in real estate and likely either don't have the existing property management relationships in each area or you chose an area where they don't have enough units through Roofstock for the PM they chose to care.

You can wind up with title issues if you are not careful. 

We care about our investors' success, but it's ultimately up to each investor to take action to accomplish their goals however they do it!

However, since you put the asset into an LLC, I am going assume you care about asset protection and further this discussion just a bit.My advice to you is to seek out local banks where much of their business is derived from commercial lending.

Sounds like you have a good plan moving forward for your investments and great markets selected for BRRRRs. 

If you plan to sell it in the near future, I would focus more on the added value overall. 

I have met a few folks recently who are active in that market and I am planning on following up and seeing what their experience has been.