But based on my criteria I would tell them that we require 3x's the rent in verifiable income with 3 consecutive pay stubs.

This is not locked out because I forgot my password it was because my identity needs to be verified.

So..... your realtor got all this info and DIDNT VERIFY ANY OF IT before accepting the applicant to move in?

It's important that you understand how your expenses and taxes effect your bottom line, so keep on doing what you are doing, but have a CPA verify that you are on the right track.

if so verify income/jobs.

@Mark WilliamsThe valuation of commercial asset (which your 24 unit building is) is driven by the NOI of the asset, the building class, the cap rate for that asset class in the area where the building is located and thit is very different from the purchase and sale of residential properties for which the value is determined by the price other people paid for similar properties.it is important to look at the P&L statement for the building you are looking to purchase and verify that it accounts for the expenses and income to work out the true NOI.The NOI divided by the cap rate and divided by the number of units would give you the price you should expect to pay.That price per unit will vary depending on the class of asset it is.Class A commands the highest price per unit and the lowest cap rateClass D commands the lowest price per unit and the highest cap rateNot the precise answer you were expecting but hope it helps.

John Sanderson , you are correct about what “notarizing a document” is for, which is why I suggested that to the OP after the very first commenter here pointed out that documents can be falsified.Someone else suggested having the prospective tenant go to the county’s tax website to verify the property owner’s identity.

Saw this recently, please verify with your accountant.

As I was on the phone, they verified that information and my LLC status immediately became active again. 

If you have a verifiable track record of successful deals, you've got a decent shot.