I have seen some interesting color schemes in the past but this one is one of the worst.  

The issue we have now though, is that it does seem that the smoke got into the attic and the beams are showing smoke coloration (see pics).

The property is a mid-century modern and judging by the color choices and the neighbors, the old owner was a bit eclectic.

I am sure that adverse possession laws vary from state to state but in my state it requires, open, notorious, hostile possession under color of title for 10 years. 

@David Cook   I have seen the 1000 dollar paint jobs in the south... they paint the windows shut no prep work and get paint everywhere  :)  we pay for new construction 2.65 a foot and that includes paint. so  1k sq ft hjouse is 2650... and so. on. but its 3 colors prep and woodwork.There is no question in the high rental areas like were you live you can get stuff done way cheaper than in many other parts of the country.

I own multiple multi family properties and get a couple a week and don't care what color they are, they're all a waste of time as I never look at unsolicited inquiries . 

For one of our rentals we painted the paneling light color and did nice white trim, looks good but we weren't selling. 

Also even if they have extra sheets laying around and you need to replace damage the color will not match perfectly.

I paint all of my the interiors of rentals the same color, a light beige.

Why not just take the concrete foundation and have a company come in and color and lay a clear coat of some kind over it?