Once you have the data, you can make better sense of After Repair Value of the property, then decide to cut your loss or hold/rent it. 

Looking to network with investors or any real estate driven individuals.

I also look at data from AirDNA but I'm uncertain about its accuracy for my area.As this would be my first time doing short-term rental, I would like to gather insights and feedback from the community at BiggerPockets, those who own properties in my area.

But, maybe that is just the way this particular lender integrates data...

My only 'two cents' is that the answer to your decision will largely be driven by your budget. 

To note is that Berkeley has very low housing supplies and a strong rental market driven by UC Berkeley.

Zillow data only gives you historical data for SFR in the metro level but not city or zip code level.Where else can I find historical rental data for a city/zip?

Many Realtors will fill out the paperwork (like the MLS data input / property information form) for their clients but never read the fine print.

:P That helps back up our decision to sell the property.Well, I am also in the business and part of my job is having access to the data.

My team and I host over 100 properties here in northern Utah and I use this data and the data of my own personal properties to help clients purchase successful investment properties.