It looks like sale prices are not required to be disclosed in Idaho.The only 2 I quickly found with prices recorded within a few blocks of you are 5275 W Madison which sold for $276,500 on 7/8/2016 and 32886 N 16th Ave which sold for $250,000 on 6/20/2016.

I believe the neighborhood is referred to as Bates-Hendricks and the units are all north of Raymond Street, east of Madison and west of I-65.  

Interesting - the market in Huntsville right now has not slowed down at all;  in fact, I would argue it is even crazier than it was 3 months ago, and is now virtually impossible to find a property to cash flow unless you go to C/D neighborhoods or go in areas that typically have zero appreciation (outside of Huntsville and Madison city limits).    

Here's a list put out by a servicer, Madison Management, that shows a breakdown.

I am currently 21 and attending school at UW-Madison.

For the deal to really work I'd like to spend $45K but not sure if that's possible.Specifically I'm interested if you agree with my rehab assessment, if there is anything you recommend I not overlook or that you think isn't that important, and how you might approach the rehab if this was your project.Here's the property:https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/9612-Madison...Here's the video walk thru:https://www.youtube.com/watch?

In Madison County, for example, "01" is the far northeast corner. 

I hear good things about lots of up-and-coming cities (Indianapolis IN, Mesa AZ, Madison WI to name a few), but I know nothing about those markets, the culture of those towns, the good and bad areas, or even how to find a good property manager over there. 

I'm thinking Madison Square Garden. 

You can Click on The Icons To See Them betterHopefully the following Table will be readable  Overall Rank Overall Rank Total Score ‘Rental Market & Affordability’ Rank ‘Quality of Life’ Rank (1 = Best) City 1 Scottsdale, AZ 69.26 14 1 2 Peoria, AZ 66.72 12 2 3 Chandler, AZ 66.41 22 3 4 Gilbert, AZ 66.16 7 9 5 Fargo, ND 63.16 2 49 6 Bismarck, ND 63 3 50 7 Overland Park, KS 61.76 17 16 8 Lincoln, NE 61.41 19 29 9 Mesa, AZ 59.56 38 23 10 Tempe, AZ 59.5 28 28 11 Irvine, CA 59.49 111 4 12 Nashua, NH 59.48 57 13 13 Sioux Falls, SD 59.15 4 86 14 Boise, ID 59.03 68 15 15 Phoenix, AZ 58.63 44 30 16 Omaha, NE 58.31 27 44 17 Lewiston, ME 57.84 23 46 18 Glendale, AZ 57.52 37 40 19 El Paso, TX 57.24 50 37 20 Cedar Rapids, IA 57.06 5 81 21 Tampa, FL 56.59 130 7 22 Charleston, SC 56.43 59 26 23 Huntsville, AL 56.3 1 121 24 Plano, TX 55.97 66 35 25 Casper, WY 55.75 6 97 26 Henderson, NV 55.59 29 59 27 Portland, ME 55.47 58 36 28 South Burlington, VT 55.37 81 25 29 San Diego, CA 55.33 157 6 30 Rapid City, SD 55.05 8 100 31 Madison, WI 54.84 53 52 32 Fremont, CA 54.54 121 18 33 Reno, NV 54.44 34 66 34 Manchester, NH 54.21 72 38 35 Orlando, FL 53.87 139 17 36 Fort Smith, AR 53.8 9 108 37 Grand Prairie, TX 53.77 97 22 38 Tucson, AZ 53.75 56 58 39 Las Cruces, NM 53.7 13 102 40 Austin, TX 53.53 76 47 41 Amarillo, TX 53.37 42 65 42 Cape Coral, FL 53.22 145 11 43 Des Moines, IA 53.01 45 68 44 Huntington Beach, CA 52.8 161 5 45 San Francisco, CA 52.55 107 41 46 Chesapeake, VA 52.43 10 118 47 Raleigh, NC 52.43 15 113 48 Las Vegas, NV 52.38 40 77 49 Newport News, VA 52.19 11 120 50 Virginia Beach, VA 52.01 24 98 51 Colorado Springs, CO 51.93 62 64 52 Honolulu, HI 51.61 160 27 53 Jacksonville, FL 51.51 91 55 54 Santa Rosa, CA 51.49 165 10 55 Cheyenne, WY 51.45 33 104 56 Chula Vista, CA 51.26 146 32 57 Sacramento, CA 50.76 149 34 58 St.