They have five-star, glowing reviews from past landlords; paid on time, quiet, etc.

  ( I wont elaborate I just hope you take this at heart and read it) .Other than that I dont have much to say because every case is different and every couple have their own personal struggles, though this guys ( IAN LOBAS)  https://www.linkedin.com/in/ianrlobas/ is a ROCK STAR on this topic and is also an RE Investor. 

as in, if all stars align would it be worth considering ?

Our finances are lined up, however, we are not pre-approved yet but am looking to get that ironed out once I narrow down the location and find my all-star agent and property management. 

So here comes the tricky part, in the best case scenario we should be able to get all of our money back and have a small cash flow from BRRR, but stars must align for it, max rent, min rehab, max ARV...

Learned on a turn key vacation rental 5 star I built in New Orleans & sold 8 years later doubled my money Did you work with any real estate professionals (agents, lenders, etc.) that you'd recommend to others?

He has 5 stars.

Greetings I'm Akil and I'm going into my second year as a Real Estate Investor. I've truly been through the gambit in terms of the various challenges I've found ways to overcome, from stepping on old and rotted water ...

You’ll see some absolute all star agents involved on BP and if you rad through their posts, the top 1% have a longer term outlook.

I know I've said it before on other posts but will say it again, he and his team are ROCK STARS and will take care of you however they can and he is my go to conventional lender without a doubt.