Would love to connect & share some resources on how to find a local mentor and id love to serve as a mentor for you in any way I can. wishing you the best!

The best way to find an investor friendly broker is at a RE meetup, but you can also just ask around in your local network or google.

I'd recommend joining local meetups. 

Find a local realtor that will sell the property when renovations are completed. 

I’d suggest checking out real estate networking events (local or online) like REIAs or BiggerPockets.

Research comps in the Milwaukee area or connect with a local appraiser to estimate your property’s potential value.Depending on the rental income, you might explore DSCR loans for your refinance, as they rely on property performance more than personal income.

@Paola Astrid Find the local NARPM (national association of residential property managers) chapter's website and you'll find a list of each professional PM. 

Contact a couple local PM’s.

Not sure if this is helpful, but I am local to Columbia, SC and have interviewed a few local companies which all seemed horrendous.

@Kieran Collings - I'm an investor, flipper, and own and run a local property management company.