Then you'd likely put more weight on the comps from the 80's then the other two in the late 90's.  

B2 (sell in 6 months when the lease expires (home buyers don’t want renters in the house and you don’t want to boot a paying tenant.)Or E) Ben’s suggestion.

Personally, I prefer to manage all my properties because a) no one cares about them more than me, b) there's no PMs in my town worth a crap anyway, c) my properties are fully renovated and rent so fast that PMs would do virtually no work for their pay anyway, d) I'm a control freak, e) I make more money. 

E's, and YSU. 

(link: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/new-jerseys-6th-distr...) 

Residentshall be responsible, at Resident’s expense, for hauling to the dump those items too large to fit in the trash containers.Resident shall not dispose of any flammable liquids, rags or other items soaked with flammable liquids or any otherhazardous material in trash containers or bins;(b) to properly use and operate all electrical, gas and plumbing fixtures and keep them as clean and sanitary as theircondition permits;(c) to keep the premises and furniture, furnishings and appliances, and fixtures, which are rented for Resident’s exclusiveuse, in good order and condition; that all rooms on the premises and all appliances and fixtures on the premises must beable to be used for their intended purpose(s);(d) not to willfully or wantonly destroy, deface, damage, impair or remove any part of the structure or dwelling unit or thefacilities, equipment, or appurtenances thereto or to permit any person on the premises, to do any such thing;(e) to occupy the premises as a residence, utilizing portions thereof for living, sleeping, cooking or dining purposes only whichwere respectively designed or intended to be used for such purposes.

@Daniel E., my guess is, renting out your primary would not cover all your $237k mortgage and its other expenses, right?

If you're thinking about moving into it in the future and having the family right there, that's a completely separate thing for you to weight versus just comparing strict investments. 

I too have ran a dummy ad on craigslist, and I did not know if that had any weight with anyone until know. 

Hi @Joe E.!