As of today, he has one 5 star and one 1 star review on Google. 

If u want long term wealth, consider SFH’s in 4-5 star neighborhoods w/ BRRRR method.

I have contacted about 5 agents that are all 5 stars reviewed and still haven't had anyone that seems to have my best interest.

A quick search of google and lending tree show 5 star ratings.

Talk about the stars aligning, congrats

And I’m also not sure how willing other investors are to share/introduce their rock star team.

You should gauge his/her comfort with tax law as it pertains to real estate.If you only have a few rentals and a standard W-2 job (i.e. you are not a real estate professional) a competent CPA who is not a rock star in real estate tax, but can play a few chords, will probably be able to add 80-100% of the same level of value as an RE CPA.On the other hand, if you are a RE professional, own lots of rentals and/or interests in syndications, and do value add/repositioning....get yourself a RE CPA.

You've jumped in with both feet and, I get it.... you're far from shore and you're just trying to do whatever it takes to end the process and get it finished.But you're doing this at your own detriment and you should thank your lucky stars that your E-File was rejected because you're just mashing buttons at this point and you're about to get yourself in trouble.Back up and just stop.Here are some statements you've made.  

Like taking your wife out to 5-star restaurant, hotel at the four seasons and then the babysitter called and said the kid is sick.

Add the extra touches such as snacks or beer/wine for your guests and keep your 5 star rating.