Too good to be true is also a huge red flag.

Fake income documents are easily purchased online, and inexperienced screeners often miss red flags.

Of course it is a red flag!

Big red flag would be her telling you not to come to town.

Although not tragic, still a small red flag - ok so 24,800 leads to go.While taking a break from the email task, I came across this BP thread - WOW! 

Red flags yet?

I instead look at it as a potential red flag.

This could definitely be a red flag, but we would need to know more beforehand.

Since they say they don't want to leave, I wouldn't try to force them out until the end of lease term if they are paying (it might look like retaliation) but if you really don't want a cat you could.Here's what I would do:I would tell the tenants that they need to address their issues with the renovations with their own insurance carrier not yours.

I spent much a day trying to get a new umbrella carrier.