I also buy vintage decor - old wooden canoes, bear rugs, fishing gear, etc.All of these things are found on Facebook Marketplace with some patience.

Before doing that, you may want to consider added more decor and texture to the property.

I would add more decor that adds color and fits the theme of the area.

@Joseph MuleroTo boost your rent plan and make more money in the medium-length rent market, think about these steps: slowly add furniture to the new place while you stay in your current home, pick cheap furniture, use a credit card with good terms, look into loan options like personal loans or home equity credit lines, try out the market by listing the place with few furniture pieces, aim for easy-to-change furniture for flexibility, and talk to pros like real estate agents or home decorators.

So, I had a local shop make her several home decor items, and one of them was a nice mug that read, "Mike can fix that".

Do you have a floor & Decor location there locally ? 

They can quote the by-laws by song and verse... be it the decoration you tenant hung on the door, or the tenant's inoperative car, or noise violations, etc, etc.I would definitely check into the rules of the HOA.  

Utilities, taxes (property, local vacation, & income), landscaping, furnishing / decorations / amenities, pest control, & supplies (soap, TP, etc) are the big ones on my STR calculator that you didn't mention.I'd also recommend using the enemy method to determine expected income.

We negotiated the furniture in the price and used some of our older furniture to update the decor.

In a saturated market with high traffic, the play is to create properties that are decorated and themed extremely well so they will pop out online.