I had another local realtor tell me it might be worth a shot at least trying to fill it as an MTR for the first 3 months of 2025 as I don't owe my first mortgage payment on my new home purchase until March 1st of 2025.

Quote from @Andrew Syrios: So basically note investing is really trashy and you're looking for a continuous stream of income but instead of alimony or child support it's loan payments instead? 

Hey Chris would love to visit.  100% of my business is helping clients in all 50 states with purchasing vacation homes/STR properties. 90% of my clients use the 10% down loan because the lower down payment requirement and rates/cost similar to a primary residence.

@Rick Soto,Both options have their pros, but here’s a way to think about it given your plan to move in 5 years:Option 1 (10% DP, 2-1 Buydown): This gives you lower payments for the first two years and saves you cash flow short-term.

We found some that would definitely cash flow with a 30% (or more) down payment.

How quickly are you able to save for a down payment?

With loan extension you might have to come up with extra payment to get DSCR in range lender will approve.That is why to go through this exercise NOW and if you know tenant wants 300k TI to extend and bank wants 300k to pay down estimated balance when new loan placed you need 600k to come up with.

This gets my mortgage payment barely at break even for LTR value, (could be negative cash flowing), and lowers to about a 6% CoC (with down payment, renov and furnishings' costs)About 1.5 pt lower than my goal and with an MAO $10K higher than I wanted.b.

If someone is buying a $600k home, putting 10% down...their monthly payment would NOT be $3,000 per month.  

If this is financing for a stabilized property rate carries more importance but rate combined with origination fees, pre-payment penalty and term in which you intend on keeping the loan in place are all considerations which together should help in deciding the best financing option.