Or split my earnings with them?

Obviously each deal is unique and requires proper due diligence. 

tough one.. generally you have a captain and then crew.where I have seen this work is through an earn in situation.

The returns may not be as high as self-managed rentals, but it’s a great way to keep earning without the stress.

They don’t factor in the quality of renovations or unique property features, which are critical when determining a true ARV.

The $1,500/sq. ft. estimate seems reasonable since 4 Dewey Ln and 597 Beavertail Rd support that pricing.One thing to consider is whether any of the comps had unique features or lot premiums that could push their price per square foot higher than what your property might command.

There really isn't much else to add or remove since it's a unique and very specific question.

I am of the opinion that the best STRs are properties that don't compete with hotels - meaning that they are 4-5 bedrooms for large groups or have a unique location/setting. 

This gives you a clear, tamper-proof view of their real earnings over the past 12 months, showing recurring vs. non-recurring deposits, average balances, and overall financial stability.

My guess is even with an assistant you will still have to do a lot of the work.As for your maintenance guy, that is definitely a unique situation!