I do think some of the advice about getting some consults with agents so you know where you are at might help, but you sound half-renovated right now.Think back and really answer, why did you buy this when you did?

There’s a 99% chance you’re going to ask to much and sit empty for an extra month or two.

I will say this is one of several same-size plots split from a larger one and the others have been split in half the same as I'm planning.

After a year and a half of him creating unnecessary issues, we decided it was time to find a new manager.

I have a W2, so the extra rental income would be reinvetsed into the property.

Once we sell our family home, my half of the proceeds should be about $300k.

Half or more even restrict LTR's, so it could be tricky if you’re thinking about renting it out down the road.

I had another person try to bargain me down to $1700/month, and said she was moving out of her dad's house and so needed room to store boxes in the extra bedrooms. 

One was making an extra $600/month while covering all of his household expenses with just 3 PadMates. 

From direct ACH, last place I thought of checking.I was suspicious though half way, but couldn't find any proof that I was charged $99 every month in his membership area, nor was there a cancel button, and there was barely any content in that area, so I thought I wasn't charged, further maybe I wasn't even a member, and stopped researching.