There are multiple factors to consider, but from what I'm reading, you're better off doing STR if you're good with more turns.

The biggest ways IMO are MLS data, multiple solutions for sellers (off market cash deal or listing), ability to rep. yourself on your own deals (saving on commission).Commission savings adds up fast when you're doing multiple deals a year.That being said, there is cost to having a license so if you're only doing a couple deals a year then it might not make as much sense.

That’s the best way to do something like this  If an LLC has multiple properties, wouldn’t that get funky adding someone for one property to an LLC?

I have had to share them with underwriters on multiple occasions 

I agree with having multiple options / viable strategies.

I find it much more useful when you have multiple properties.  

Had the ONLY beneficiary been an SDIRA, or even multiple SDIRAs, they'd have been fine.  

HelloIf I get the duplicated house information from two agents and I go for one of them, would it be unethical? Or does this happen so often and they really dont care?

I have called multiple supervisors and they all have said they don't know the applicants pay.

If you can get into something with multiple units and live in one, you can STR the other units; just be ready to purchase something north of $1m for that strategy.