You could look into forming a C Corp as an alternative way to own this property that could affect your tax returns differently, I am not a CPA or giving tax advise.

I also sent another message 7 days before, just reminding them that we offer different packages if they haven't already gotten one.

you will hear different opinions.

Currently operating in 10 different markets across the Mid-south and Southeastern regions and would love to connect with you on what your goals are. 

Split the difference, 57,500.

There's no one right answer for everyone since we all have different financial situations and risk tolerances.  

Someone could claim you discriminated if you rejected them or implied you woudl then do something different for someone else.Hope this helps.

I'll throw in my 2 cents on common differences I've seen in my career:CDFIs - Because of their subsidized financing structure, they have the ability to be a low cost lender (and sometimes provide grants).

Also @Andrew Syrios thank you for your opinion also, it´s pretty much helpful to have different opinions and perspectives, but still difficult to decide when someone it´s just beginning.  

Understand the fees involved and calculate the total cost for an entire year of management so you can compare the different managers.