They did not communicate the scope well to the plumber, who it sounds like should not have been involved in the first place I would have a point-blank conversation about the above with your manager and ask who he or she thinks should cover the waste of paying multiple professionals to shuffle a thin plastic piece underneath an appliance the tenant was responsible for installing in the first place.

That would be nice, but I suspect that I will somehow be involved in it...?

My AC unit has another 3-5 years before it’ll need to be replaced so I’m thinking this may be a clean exit before large big ticket items start needing attention in the next 5 years.

@Abigail KingStarting a first house hack in Peoria, IL involves researching, education, financing options, and management tips.

OrhiOrhi,You may wanna read the thread below before taking a Property Management recommendation from Bob.Who is Bob Stevens AKA Bob Prisco and what's his involvement in Cleveland? 

It is actually a little more involved than that sounded but you should get the point.

It would involve putting an external staircase on the side of the house and making the second bathroom into a full bath.

Guest checks out, cleaners arrive to clean, conduct post stay inspection, and reset the home for next guest.

What did your management contract state about screening prospective tenants and your involvement? 

Depending on the ARV, I think you are better of using your own cash or getting a partner involved to finish the rehab and then cash out refinance with a conventional or DSCR loan.