I don't like AI descriptions (sorry @Andrew Steffens).They look and sound completely like it was written by a bot, which it was.I like to write my own copy for listings and I respond directly to all guests, inquiries and issues.

In our opinion it is not worth the price to evict that many tenants as SCI will lose a lot of money in the process.

Acquisition,  processing, etc. perhaps. 

We learned through this process that when we don't have the answers, we need to ask for help.

Often times, their approval processes are slow.Credit Unions - Their member structure also subsidizes their financial structure so they can also be a source of low-cost financing.

Here is what I would do:I would still close on the property but send a letter to the sellers broker and the seller along the lines of below (note I would have an attorney write it and send it):It has been brought to our attention there was a $15,000 insurance claim on the property.

I would get the new tenant to apply and process it per your criteria.  

Start with a standard offer, and write a contingency into it for electricity, all the below ground utilities, and then work your way to zoning, permitting etc.

Did you write a check out to that title company for the EMD?

If your leasing application process is thorough and well thought out, and if your lease agreement has been well drafted by your local attorney and if it includes clauses that permit you/your property manager enough latitude to maneuver and anticipate undesirable tenant behaviors, both actions and inactions, and you have operational processes which align with enforcement of your lease, then you've done all you can do to reduce this inherent risk of an undesirable tenant.