Also, don't bid until they are approaching your max.

@Diana Mulvihill listen to your gut just work on your pricing strategy and do your best to maximize revenue.

It really makes a difference when you use pros that specialize in REI and how they can help your money work for you. 

Move-Out Checklist for Investment PropertyA well-structured move-out checklist helps protect your investment, ensures a smooth tenant transition, and reduces turnover costs.Tenant Responsibilities (Before Move-Out)✅ Provide written notice of intent to vacate (per lease terms)✅ Schedule a move-out inspection (if required)✅ Pay all outstanding rent and utilities✅ Remove all personal belongings and trash✅ Clean the unit thoroughly:Wipe down walls, baseboards, and doorsVacuum and mop floorsClean kitchen appliances (inside/out)Wipe down cabinets and countertopsScrub bathroom sinks, toilets, showers/tubs✅ Replace any missing or burned-out light bulbs✅ Repair any tenant-caused damage (holes, broken blinds, etc.)✅ Return all keys, garage remotes, and access cards✅ Provide a forwarding address for the security deposit refundLandlord/Property Manager Responsibilities✅ Conduct a pre-move-out inspection (optional)✅ Take photos/videos of the property’s condition✅ Verify all keys, garage remotes, and access cards are returned✅ Check for unpaid rent, utilities, or damages beyond normal wear and tear✅ Hire a cleaning service (if needed)✅ Complete repairs and maintenance (paint, flooring, appliances, HVAC, plumbing)✅ Change locks if required by state law or property policy✅ Test smoke detectors and carbon monoxide alarms✅ Review lease terms for security deposit deductions✅ Send tenant security deposit refund (minus any deductions) within the legal timeframe

. - When we've review these options with clients the ending outcome is typically that it's easier to forgo the 121 exclusion if you want to keep this property; and do a cash-out refinance (taking on more debt isn't taxable) instead. 

@Edward Barrett it is really a mixed bag. 

Also a ton about it here https://www.biggerpockets.com/blog/renovation-toolkit

Do you have any CPA recommendations for me?

@Nathan Gesner had a pretty robust post on how to do that some weeks back.Another problem that is getting in your way is the use of term leases here in NY. 

If the gap still exists, is it more narrow today than it was during the lower rate environment?