As long as comps don't reflect those highly upgraded sidings most investors would go with the cheaper option if the purpose is to maximize benefits on the refinance. 16k for siding sounds high if it's a 1000-1500 sqft home

Sounds like they are bitter.

This is what it sounds like, you lease the garage to a parking operator.

I'm a novice, but this sounds interesting!

Partnering with family and securing owner financing to acquire the property below asking price was a smart move, and the renovations sound like they added significant value.As a direct lender, I’d love to explore how we might assist with your future growth, especially as you look to scale into larger multi-family investments.

I am thinking of doing a 1031 exchange with them but not sure if it all sounds too good to be true?

That rate does not sound out of line for an STR.

It sounds like you want checkbook control, @Katie Accashian  In this case, you need a special-purpose LLC.

sounds like it must have been a big house. 

Sounds a bit like a paradox.