@Emily Runyan Have you tried reaching out to ALE Solutions?

If they can't close on their house, they will have to figure out a temporary solution.

In the worst-case scenario, I might have to deal with negative cash flow and stay in the property longer than planned, delaying my second investment until I find a good solution.

You will want to make sure you are installing something new that provides the right solution not just putting back something that matches but doesn't do the right thing in the first place.You may also want to consider rain gutters because doesn't look like the roof has much of a drip edge. 

I do know of some builders and lenders in the area that are organizing to create solutions for people who are stuck because a builder can't finish the job. 

Hostfully is more robust and a more complete solution to Hospitable.

But organizing those vetted people is a HUGE portion of your solution.  

open to other financial creative solutions I may not be aware off.

He’s affiliated with Dave Ramsey solutions but I think that is a benefit in my case.

It's not ideal working in multiple systems but it's the most cost effective solution we have found.