My wife and I did our own taxes using some program (I don't think it was TurboTax, but maybe.)

You're going to have to scrap like crazy to break even - think rent by the room, short term, mid term strategies that require more work.

If not, does anyone think I can tackle this on my own?

But I think I would need to see more data to make an informed decision.

I think Brett has a Facebook group, let's keep in touch there.

I think anytime someone has one rental, they should get professional help.

I think the idea of starting fresh financially, as soon as possible, would eliminate a lot of stress.

I think a great strategy would be to find someone who would like to house hack with you, and maybe even someone with a bit of experience local to the area that you trust and know very well to go in on the deal with you.  

Having them pay your LLC does not protect you from anything if that is what you were thinking.

Didn’t think so.