If not, you might have to pursue legal means which would differ depending on your state/county.Honestly, I hate security deposit dispositions.

- If you have experience pursuing tenants, what approach did you take?

I would pursue both and see what lands.  

If you think there's a deal worth pursuing, it's generally a good idea to buy.

Should I keep pursuing this or let it go? 

The time and energy you will spend pursuing a remedy is not worth it.  

Happy to chat about that if you'd like to pursue that just send me a message and can find time.

However, if you read through the majority of the posts on this thread, the general consensus would dissuade you from pursuing the cost that Anderson charges for that level protection and the charging order protection of filing the LLC in WY. 

We received the payout in about 30 days and were able to rehab the unit and get it rented again promptly.From my understanding of the situation, if the tenant did not have the renter's policy in place, our own landlord policy would most likely have covered it, but they could also have pursued the tenant to collect those damages.

@Chad Lundquist It's best to pursue something both you and your wife are comfortable purchasing.