@Keith HebertMy gut says you’re overpaying.

I just look at the fundamentals and often just trust my gut. 

My current full gut rehab is running around $85 per sqft on a 105 year old home.

Instinctively, I did the only thing that made sense..

It was gutted and all new tiles, bath tub, toilet bowl installed. 

I would suggest a company that removes the windows to restore them at a facility off-site, unless this will be a completed gutted site or you are not on a strict timeline due to lead safety and RRP compliance.

They caught me off guard as I didn't want to delay my closing and allowed my emotions to take over first vs trusting my gut instinct!

I purchased a single family home in the suburbs just north of Boston- approximately 1300 sq ft/ 3BR,1BA and I'm in the process of gutting it.

So yes, they got the property but it was half finished or completely gutted, they couldn't find anyone to work on it, and much of what had been done hadn't been permitted so they found the properties that they received as security pretty much useless or requiring so much money to finish that it caused them to go bankrupt.   

Seems like nobody thinks they are going to be the guy that loses everything until they do, which is why its helpful to me to have  good "gut check" from others with more experience.