If you could work it into a combination STR/MTR and rent mid-term to people working in the area for the down months, the market could work, but aside from that I don't see a ton of value in that market for the prices you have to pay, you basically have to make a years worth of expenses in a 4-5 month span.I don't have specific knowledge of any of the other markets on the list, but based on this one it seems like not much analysis went in to any of these properties and its strictly based on a rough estimates of revenue.

Or you could buy a single-family home with the VA loan and turn it into the rental, but you should still do the same analysis on the rent and expenses after you move out.

What are the best websites that monitor trends in populations and real estate for USA? on local and regional levelSuch as: Where are populations moving from and to? Where are prices rising and falling and for which ty...

So project selection, detailed comp analysis, detailed cost analysis, an ARV based on fact. 

I'm working on launching a STR reporting product designed to make data analysis accessible for everyone, even if you're not a data geek!

@Nicholas FoutzReal estate investors should focus on genuine relationships and accurate property analysis for fix-and-flip deals.

They will even provide a proforma and will assist with deal analysis.

Data and Analysis Tools: Making Informed DecisionsReal estate investing is about more than just buying properties; it’s about making smart investments that will give you a strong return over time.

@Jay ShahTo enhance your real estate investing confidence, consider educating yourself with courses and books on deal analysis, property management, and house hacking.

On another note your “numbers analysis” may not pan out when you take into account repairs needed as revealed by inspection reports; and this may be the reason you don’t move forward without further seller concessions.