It is not legitimate and I do not legally owe this balance, but have been unable to get it removed from my history unless I file suit against the company.

If the insurance isn't done properly, it's on the edge of impossible to cash the check because it's made out to the lender, my company, and the seller(s). 

I've had tax companies lie to me about this and I ended up wasting money on unnecessary entities.

The macroeconomics for Columbus Ohio are on fire especially with population growth, job growth, and companies moving/developing here so there's amazing appreciation as well.

I have been on New Western's deal list as well as another bigger local company and everytime I underwrite these deals there is very very minimal left on the bone let alone contingency funds for going over budget on the flip...

With your experience and possible skillset, perhaps finding a company to sponsor you for a green card may be a better option? 

Some carriers won't allow insured to be a trust, so in that case do it in your company name with trust as additional insured.

@Bobby Paquette, someone had asked about this group a while back and I will say, there is a lot that scares me about this company.  

If you don’t, maybe work with or for an existing company first for awhile?

We learn to build relationships with people and companies.