The STR market here has become way more saturated and competitive especially in San Juan. 

My goal is to make this property available to insurance companies, disaster recovery specialists, and individuals displaced by fire, flood, or other catastrophic events.I am seeking guidance on the most effective approach to market this property, specifically:Recommended Insurance and Disaster Recovery ContactsAre there specialized companies that manage temporary housing for insurance claims?

@Abigail Kingprimarily off market although, i've started to engage on on-market deals if i think they will fitvery difficult to find

Make sure you learn the markets.

I Can only realistically get $1600-$1700 a month renting my house based on the market.

Never considered it a market to invest in.

Purchase price: $35,000 Cash invested: $35,000 Sale price: $110,000 A fix-and-flip project purchased off-market from a tired landlord involved buying a distressed property with significant deferred maintenance.

@Annabelle Rozen  I believe the stability of the rental market within Allentown is rather robust. 

Southern Maine is a great market for long-term rentals, with strong demand in many areas.

Are they at market rent, or locked into below-market rates?