But PadSplit does not handle maintenance and any member communications, our management covers that. 

However the negative reviews have been consistent for a few years, and still recently, so that is a concern.

Choosing markets with direct flight access simplifies logistics.After setup, frequent visits are unnecessary if you have a reliable team and good communication.

If you are able to network with someone that can give you consistent deal flow and partner with people that will provide the funding you will be in really good shape.

Even small, consistent amounts add up over time.Learn & NetworkKeep reading REI books, but also join real estate meetups or online groups like here on BiggerPockets.

You will note there is no mention above about being a good communicator. 

Working with contractors can be extremely difficult as projects get delayed and there is poor communication(red flags were not present before project began).

Asking travelers to communicate via platforms or services outside of Vrbo before accepting a booking (such as through email or text).

His communication is poor but he continues to advertise for his several businesses.

Certainly track record is very important, but track record is so much more than deal performance.The last decade was a consistent bull market so almost anyone could put some runs on the scoreboard while learning little to nothing.