You won't need to do anything if the victim does the right thing with the police and courts.

The only way this will become something you can charge the tenant for is if the courts find them responsible for the actual act. 

But the law is being challenged in court as government confiscation of property - which it effectively is.

Constables, sheriffs, and even the courts can screw up for various reasons.

The veil of the LLC can be pierced by the courts in certain circumstances.

You could take him to small claim's court or rally the larger family to guilt the heck out of him - but I think there's something more you should be doing:  taking care of you.You need a better housing solution. 

This would likely fall into the amount appropriate for small claims court.

well PMI is why.So bottom line depends on the market and the opening bids.. and the process.. its still viable in a few markets I fund folks that buy court house steps stuff monthly.. 

The more you and the resident make it look like they are the owner responsible for maintenance, the more the court could decide they have equitable interest in the property and you have to foreclose to get it back.

Your written partnership agreement will be Exhibit A in court.