Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Zeek Collins

Zeek Collins has started 2 posts and replied 10 times.

Post: Japan Apartment Buildings

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1

Hello, I recently returned from an internship in the countryside of Japan. I know that everyone talks about the declining value of Japanese Real Estate. However, during my time there, my landlord was living happily near the beach with a big home, a new BMW, and a 36-unit apartment building (3 floors, 12 units per floor). The guy worked at a 7-11 for fun on the weekends. I know that most people are trying to make revenue on their real estate from the sale of the building itself. However, am I crazy to want to just hold onto the building and rent it out until it has no value? Below is my response to common points often brought up when it comes to the apartment building situation.

1. I also know that people are hesitant to buy property because of the aging population of Japan. But, also due to the aging population you have people like my landlord; whose children don't want to inherit the property because they live in a different area of the country.  This means that there are properties in very lucrative areas at a great price but, no buyers. Of course I'd choose a place closer to a train station in a larger city but, I'm not looking to make insane profits. I just want enough stable revenue to pay yearly expenses, hire a property management team, and pay the debt preferably in 5-10 years. I'm 22 the only thing I'm rich in is time.

2. It could just be me but, I know apartment buildings are heavily slept upon. If you buy in an area like Kanagawa, Tokyo, Osaka, Nagoya, or Fukuoka even; I find it very hard to believe that those areas won't find people living there in the next 100 years. it's not nearly as hard to find properties in a good location as we are made to believe. If you do decent research or have traveled to the area the story tells itself. For example, if you're in a place where there's a bunch of old people and most stores are closed past 3 pm that's not the place you want to be.

 3. I know another argument is that people want to live in new properties. Which is fair everyone does. I know I did.  However, if I have a low salary and this building is a little older but has good upkeep, the rent is fair and my landlord is decent. It's a no-brainer what I'm going with. Not to mention my Japanese friends who are in college all have cheap apartments by the college because they don't want to wake up at 5 am for a 2-hour commute to school. Because the colleges rarely have dorms. There will always be a buyer for an older apartment as long as the conditions are decent and the location is right. 

4. Getting Capital: Me personally, I have no clue. I am merely an overly passionate young adult chasing my white whale that is owning an apartment in Japan. 

I am putting this together just in case there is also someone who is as crazy as myself on BiggerPockets who has taken the leap or will take the leap in the future to see later down the line. All comments are appreciated and if my ignorance of the industry annoys you. Please use comedic insults only and I will take into consideration what you have to say. 

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1

I’m definitely going to start looking into wealth building because I wasn’t planning on selling anything as long as it brought in stable income or I needed money for a downpayment on a property with a higher yield. I do have a question. What exactly are the Classifieds? Is it a website or a thread on BiggerPockets? Once again thanks so much you all have been extremely helpful. @Mike Lambert @Kevin Ing

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1
Quote from @Kevin Ing:
Quote from @Mike Lambert:

@Zeek Collins Maybe @Kevin Ing can comment on bank financing. Probably, you won't be able to get a mortgage as a foreigner. I don't even know if a Japanese resident can get a mortgage on a commercial property that's not based on his/her personal income as the value of the asset is at a high risk of depreciation and the LTV would increase over time and go over 100%. Also, refinancing isn't available in many countries and would make even less sense in Japan for that exact same reason. Also, the population decrease is a huge issue that has no solution.

All Japanese real estate investors I know invest out of their country. I totally understand that you don't want to invest in the US but there are other countries in the world that don't have those issues. That's what I'm doing with my investors and plenty of other investors Arte doing the same.

Bank financing should be possible, even to non-Japanese... however, there will be more hurdles. Since the bank is always concerned with risk management for getting their money back, it helps to have things such as:
- Permanent residency
- Japanese spouse
- Larger than usual down payment
- Financially secure loan guarantor who is Japanese and willing to sign for you (you will probably need the guarantor regardless, but having one with deep pockets helps)

Sorry, I don't have experience with commercial property here. My property was purchased as a primary residence, but later circumstances necessitated that I turn it into a rental property.

The Japanese banks are going to be probably the greatest hurdle. I can definitely get the money for a down payment on a property but, if the banks never give me an option to get a loan is a whole different beast. I appreciate your on-the-ground knowledge. You make it way easier to understand what is and isn't possible.

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1
Quote from @Mike Lambert:

@Zeek Collins Maybe @Kevin Ing can comment on bank financing. Probably, you won't be able to get a mortgage as a foreigner. I don't even know if a Japanese resident can get a mortgage on a commercial property that's not based on his/her personal income as the value of the asset is at a high risk of depreciation and the LTV would increase over time and go over 100%. Also, refinancing isn't available in many countries and would make even less sense in Japan for that exact same reason. Also, the population decrease is a huge issue that has no solution.

All Japanese real estate investors I know invest out of their country. I totally understand that you don't want to invest in the US but there are other countries in the world that don't have those issues. That's what I'm doing with my investors and plenty of other investors Arte doing the same.


 Just out of curiosity where do you think would be best for someone like myself? Singapore was an option from what I remember. Also, wouldn't it be ok if the asset value plummeted but, you managed to make the money back through rent? Like an exchange of sorts.

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1
Quote from @Account Closed:


Wow, Japan sounds like a great opportunity! It's cool that you're studying airport management and thinking about real estate. Getting a loan and starting a company sounds like a big step, but if you're serious about it, living there first seems like a smart move. 

Have you thought about any part-time work to save up some capital? It might take time, but with your study abroad experience, you could find something cool.


 I work at a Law firm currently but, school is still expensive with scholarship money as expected. I got an internship to return to another area of Japan so I'm looking forward to seeing real estate in a smaller city.

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1
Quote from @Kevin Ing:
Quote from @Zeek Collins:
Quote from @Mike Lambert:

Hi Zak, there is nothing wrong in being a newbie but, when you buy overseas, you really need to know what you’re doing, Things are different and you can’t just apply what works in the US, especially in Japan, where the market behaves in a unique fashion.


If I were you, I’d stay away from Japanese real estate and especially apartment buildings. It works differently there. Their value goes to 0 over time. Generally speaking, nobody wants to live in older buildings there so they get empty and then get demolished.

I see. Do you think that if you had a good location that could help? My dorm happened to be an older building but, due to the close proximity to two colleges and a station I’m pretty sure it was successful . I thought if you had a building close enough to a campus and rent cheap enough for college students to afford then there was a chance to have a consistent flow of revenue. Or, perhaps a good train line that feeds into major city areas like Shinjuku or Shibuya. I appreciate your input it’s helping me a lot to think about the Japanese mindset when it comes to rental properties.
I think there are a few things to consider for investing in Japan. Even though I live in Tokyo, love living in Japan, and own a rental home, I am not looking to expand my portfolio here.

1. Location is king. Most people in Tokyo use public transportation, so properties near popular train or subway stations are best. Far from stations, or less popular lines are not great for investment, IMO.

2. No to low capital gains. Most people believe that the structure depreciates to 0 value in 25 years, leaving only the land that has value. If you've got a good location, then the value can trend upwards -- especially if the area is seeing redevelopment. Bad locations tend to be flat or trend down.

3. Flat rents. Salaries in Japan have been more or less flat for decades. It's also very uncommon (perhaps just socially unacceptable) to raise rents/prices. For now things here are still stuck in a non-growth mode. So rental income can be tricky, and you could end up losing value if you're only getting meager cash flow here.

 Yes, the salaries not changing is something I definitely remember from my days in class. Maybe there is a way to prosper in rental properties. I found a place for 100,000 USD a while ago that had a kombini underneath the building and was 3 minutes from a Chou Line Station and I think about that a lot. 

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1
Quote from @Mike Lambert:

@Zeek Collins

First of all, my apologies for misspelling of your name. I guess a good location could help and it's likely that some buildings in downtown Tokyo maintain their value better. However, I'm not sure why you'd want to partake in a system of value/wealth destruction rather than value/wealth building. It's also unlikely you'd get financing and, isn't taking debt on a depreciating assets one of the big no-nos?

@Matthew Kwan I'm a Canadian international investor and there are so many better choices that Vancouver and Singapore would be some of the last places where I'd invest. Actually people who do don't invest there, they park their (substantial amount of) money. Let's focus on Vancouver, which I know better and I suspect Singapore is a similar story for what I know about it.

I don't know any Canadian investor in wealth building mode who'd want to invest in Vancouver, including those who live there. As a Canadian, I can invest there but wouldn't with a 10-foot pole. And there are good reasons why we wouldn't:

1. You can't get any cash flow, regardless of how high the interest rates are. Also, the law favours the tenant and so many owners have no incentives to sell and you have all these empty properties that have been bought by foreigners to park their money in a safe place. It's therefore a pure capital gain and therefore speculative market.

2. The Vancouver market is already one of the if not the most unaffordable in the world, which reflects the fact that prices are in bubble territory whichever measure you use. All levels of governments are doing their best to stop prices going up, decrease them and getting more revenue by taxing foreign owners. Not only you'd be against the government's interests but they've already proven they won't hesitate to arbitrarily infringe on your property rights.

Why anyone would want to invest in a market where cash flow is deeply negative, the laws favor tenants  and the government does anything they can to prevent you from getting capital gains of taxing them mightily if you do get them is beyond my understanding.

While it might make sense for a wealthy Chinese to park their money safely in a Vancouver property and not care about making money with it, it won't make sense for the average BP member who's in wealth creation mode. And I'm not sure how it'd apply to someone like Zeek, who isn't even legally allowed to buy now and wouldn't have access to the money anyway.


No worries about the name! Thanks for the input on Canada. I had a friend who mentioned that it was expensive but, I had no idea that it was that bad. The U.S similarly has bad tenant laws that's why I am not too interested in the market. Not to mention how little the dollar benefits me here. I was looking at Japan from a generational standpoint. Yes, I would probably lose value in the apartment buildings. But, once I pay off my first property I could take a loan out against the property for additional cheap properties. I was thinking perhaps good locations with a decent amount of properties would be sufficient. given that I was bringing in enough to make sure that I could pay everything off yearly and pocket a few thousand for savings or renovations. Then in an area like Tokyo where things are being built often, I could perhaps sell for land value if a company ever wanted an area I bought. I think that the writing on the wall is just a no from what I am hearing though. I appreciate your thoughts very much.

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1
Quote from @Matthew Kwan:

HI Zeek,

The good thing about investing in the US is that you can have a fixed loan rate for 30years which is not common in SE Asia or other countries. You can always start off by house hacking meaning you live in one UNIT or ROOM and renting out the other vacant units/rooms to offset your monthly mortgage payment. Also, the good thing about primary is that it only requires you to put as little as 3.5%-5% for properties up to 1-4 unit or 0% if you are a VA.

There are several ways to run and make sure you are maximizing your rental income while keeping your living expense as low as possible. Try looking into zillow/Redfin and see what your potential rents you can get near the neighborhood by filtering the bedrooms/bathrooms of the intentional property that you are planning to buy. This will allow you give a reference point on how much potential rent you can receive. (Max vacated rents - your monthly mortgage payment) = +/- net cashflow. 

If you are looking to be a foreign investor, I would recommend you looking into Singapore/Vancouver, Canada. There are some good incentives for US citizens to invest in Singapore. As for real estates in Canada, they are currently banning all foreigners to buy real estates in Canada until 2027. Also, there will be a 20% stamp duty tax that imposes on all foreigner investors. However, there is definitely a huge potential especially Vancouver, CA 

Happy to connect and assist you in your real estate investing journey.

@Albert Bui @Carlos Valencia


 I see that's pretty smart! I'll definitely try that trick! It does suck how 30 Year fixed rates don't exist but, I totally can understand why. I've never considered Singapore before but, perhaps I'll start looking that way. 

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1
Quote from @Mike Lambert:

Hi Zak, there is nothing wrong in being a newbie but, when you buy overseas, you really need to know what you’re doing, Things are different and you can’t just apply what works in the US, especially in Japan, where the market behaves in a unique fashion.


If I were you, I’d stay away from Japanese real estate and especially apartment buildings. It works differently there. Their value goes to 0 over time. Generally speaking, nobody wants to live in older buildings there so they get empty and then get demolished.

I see. Do you think that if you had a good location that could help? My dorm happened to be an older building but, due to the close proximity to two colleges and a station I’m pretty sure it was successful . I thought if you had a building close enough to a campus and rent cheap enough for college students to afford then there was a chance to have a consistent flow of revenue. Or, perhaps a good train line that feeds into major city areas like Shinjuku or Shibuya. I appreciate your input it’s helping me a lot to think about the Japanese mindset when it comes to rental properties.

Post: International Real Estate

Zeek CollinsPosted
  • Posts 10
  • Votes 1

This is my first post so I apologize for my lack of knowledge in the industry. I'm 21 and study airport management. I recently did a study abroad in Japan last year and am sure that you can make a killing in the Japanese market due to the decreased yen value and the lower apartment building costs and real estate as a whole compared to the States. With Japan's population getting older and major cities getting more popular with young people. I have seen some amazing deals around $100,000-$500,000 for 5-16 unit properties depending on the city.  Of course, many more fees go into the final sale of the property but, I still believe it would still be cheaper than trying to buy a home in the US. Japan also does not have laws preventing foreigners from purchasing property in their country. I don't have any capital for the purchase of a property and I fear that I may miss out on this opportune time to get into the market. I've researched a few banks that would offer me a business loan to be able to start a company to purchase property. But, I have to live in the country beforehand to get a loan. I have also reached out to some of the real estate companies for information on insurance fees and rental company costs that go into the monthly operations of apartment buildings. However, without any actual capital; I'm gaining knowledge with no way to take action. I'm hoping that someone here can help assist me in how to proceed with my situation. If you're still reading, thank you very much.