Hi Aaron and welcome to the club
I would certainly advise to start locally in your vicinity. Old properties may be more profitable if you are taking care of your business personally. Don't use management for old properties because management companies tend to use contractors for all maintenance which cost a lot more than if you bring a handyman to fix whatever needs to be fixed. In addition, upgrading old properties will appreciate the value of the property. Therefore, old properties in your area is not a reason not to start there. Just make your calculations for rent, renovation, taxes, insurance, utilities, and maintenance to make sure that you are making the right investment.
If you decide to invest away from home, then get very sound property that would need the minimum maintenance.
The last thing I would say is that you should put your money as a downpayment (20-30%) of property cost and get a loan, this way you will be increasing your cash to cash return as well as your long term profit from property appreciation because you will be able to buy more properties when using loans.