I have thought about this alot too and came to the conclusion that I would not pay off rentals early. Reasons why:
- lower returns
- I buy for cash flow
- considering loan rates I do not care about paying off a 4.8% loan fixed for 30 years
- If you get sued by a tenant then 100% of the equity could be lost if the house is paid for, versus only 25% or so in a leveraged home
- I like to keep the extra money for reserves or acquiring other rentals
In Texas my primary residence is homesteaded. So if I ever had an itch to pay off a home it would be that one, not a rental. Then again my primary residence is 3.7% for 30 years so again I see no reason to pay off a 3.7% loan. I like the idea of using the money that I would have used to pay off the primary going towards other RE investments or some other kind of investment that pays 8% or 15% or 20% etc.
I also think that paying off a rental would cost you more than you think. Reason why is because you might have the tendency to get lazy. When a unit becomes vacant you may not have the urgency to get it back up and running with new tenants...thereby costing you money each day. Maybe not but I can see how that could happen since there is not that monthly note to deal with.
Really leverage is what makes RE such a good investment. I can see how paying off rentals may give piece of mind but in reality it makes for a poor investment. When I am older I may change my mind but not right now especially with the current loan rates.