Originally posted by @Victoria C.:
Thanks all for the input! I notified my property manager and they sent in a warning notice right away, and the tenant agreed to stop and take down the posting and continue to finish out their lease as their primary residence. I saw on their listing that they have several other AirBnbs and have gotten great reviews, so this isn't their first rodeo. And to be honest, I've never seen my house look so good! They had 18 reviews just in the month of June alone, all 5 star ratings and majority of the reviews mentioned how clean it was. The house is not in a vacation area, but probably used for work conferences or to visit family... it was tempting to do an addendum to the contract for 25% of the profit and have the tenant take all the risk, but at the same time, I work 10+ hour days, and really don't have the bandwidth to keep track. But looking at the numbers, it would have been nice. This is the first property I bought and house hacked, and its kind of nice to see all the great input from the people that stayed there. They made it really nice, so I was a bit torn. If they were upfront and honest the first go round, it probably would have been a different story.
Thanks again for everyone's input! I'm quoting my previous response since it looks like some have missed it. I tend to agree with @Jerry W. and his point of view on being able to profit and learn from them. However, I do work a lot of hours and have no time to really get into it. I never thought I would do AirBnB; however, I did listen to one of the BP podcasts and heard about the positive aspects of it, and so when this tenant's side business came about, it got my wheels turning.
Also, another factor is that this is the first property I ever bought (Pre-BP) without the intention of getting much positive cashflow, but just to buy and become a homeowner with the possibility of renting it out. It turns out that the rent just clears the mortgage, water/utilities and property management costs, so it's paying for itself, but no positive cashflow. I'm holding onto it for equity and possibly moving back to it. The idea of making profit is very tempting to me when I see it being AirBnB'd; however, after a few days of thinking about it, I'm happy with a stable long term renter, with the least amount of headaches. Also, I do care about the neighborhood and would not like it being an AirBnB. After this tenant's lease is up, I plan to raise the rent and possibly be my own property manager. Right now, I have no contact with the tenant; it is all through the pm, and they handled it pretty well as far as notifying them that it's against the contract and would require a certified letter stating they will no longer sublet. The tentant was very compliant and took the listing off that same morning. As far as my fears of having a horrible tenant as a first time landlord, I would say this isn't a bad situation to be in. Thanks all! I appreciate all the info.