Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Venice Victory

Venice Victory has started 2 posts and replied 19 times.

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Venice Victory:
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Venice Victory:

That's it, that is the question!

How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k? Explain.

I really like this question for discussion Venice, but one very major factor left off is at what risk exposure. 

Example; 

I am invested in a fund that does active option plays on Tesla. Most would think it insanely astronomical returns, and it is, but it's also exceptionally high risk. So it's weighted returns. 

Conversely, a new built A class SFR, in A class market of significant growth via a well laid out planned city development, great schools, area people are glamouring to move to, a-class tenants, very very low risk. So in that a much lower rate of return is acceptable given the safety and certainty level of things.

And those factors of risk exposure and weighted returns, drastically change how much capital I'd be comfortable to outlay, for a $40k annual return. 

If were talking the later, I'd be a very happy camper at $6.85m. 

If talking the former, I'd consider up to $600k. 


 Thanks for the feedback and contributions. Not sure if it's because you started with my name but this response makes me feel more safe to share more details.

Its an interesting multifamily that was repositioned to be rented out by bedroom with the majority of the rents being paid by nonprofits. 

There is steady supply of renters, "guaranteed" rent and the organization wants to continue to partner. I'm not sure how the current political impacts this. Current owner says there weren't impacted the last time it shutdown. A motivated seller could say anything to close. Any insight here would be helpful? 

I want happy campers in my network - you've helped reiterate any deal can be good at the right purchase price.

Huh, well, that is a kudos on your level of research or you've got some serious luck on your side because as chance has it I have experience working both with organizations similar to what you described and in leasing by the room. 

First thing to know is these organizations love to convey the highest level of certainty, assurance in longevity, yada-yada. But the moment you say "well that sounds awesome, can you get that over to me in writing" it instantly turns into uhm's ah's and but's. 

There funding is almost never secured for more then a year at a time. That's your first hurdle, to find out the status of there funding. Not promised or planned, actually funded. 

Next, press and negotiate to find what you can get for the longest commitment possible. I have known one to get a 10yr commitment. In that it had a kind of early-termination clause. It wasn't called that but worked similar that if ended sooner then the 10yrs there was a financial hit for each yr not honored. 

You have to start there because the only thing you can use is what's known. So if it's 1yr commitment, use that and assume after that it's over and base analysis on what you'd have to do to make it market tenancy. 

And onto the room rental side of things. Short-short version it's hell on wheels. 

Yes, some specialize in this and do very well but it's really nothing like any other tenancy model. It has the highest turnover rate, and the highest level of active inputs. Not to mention sky-high drama factor. You have multiple people living in each others spaces. And keep in mind who it is that would be living by the room. 

Combine those factors and start thinking of nightmare scenarios, because they are very real and you must be proactive in policing against there potential to occur. 

It's best to have a house manager. I'd argue absolutely necessary. 

You also have to think about outfitting common spaces, how your going to do that, and how your going to do it in a way that keeps the "village" happy and nice with everyone. Yes well defined rule are very important and help but these are humans were talking about so you have to go deeper then that and consider that human aspect for community/shared spaces. 

You will be providing other services if smart, things like great high speed wifi, cable isn't a bad idea as it's a good pacifier. Setting up out door grilling space, because if you don't they will so it's a matter of do you want it at random or by designation. 

Oh yeah, there is a whole lot to it. Hence why there is the $ that some are flashing. 

And I am betting the headaches is why seller is so motivated and is flashing that $ and hyping it up like it's so profitable, yeah come on do it, it's so great..... it's so great they are chomping at the bit to get out from under it. 

If in your shoes I think I'd call sellers bluff and put em against the wall of it via how I construct the purchase offer. I wouldn't do it on a cash-out basis, I'd keep em tied to it. I'd do it on a terms deal. 3yr in total. 

If all is good, there should be no problem with that, right. 

Think of it like buying an existing performing business. There is always a transition period where selling owner stays on and over time new owner transitions into full control. Similar to that. 

Lastly, your going to want to get with local governance, a lot more then normal. Don't just find out how it's all licensed and check on any historical issues with it, no you want to meet with local board members, find out how they really feel about the place and what the cities wants and plans are for the place. Rarely do they like such units being operated in such way. You want to know where you stand before jumping in the pot. 

And who knows, maybe what seems bad can bring better opportunities. 

I had one once, a rooming house buy. Turned out, city board hated the place. Hated it so much, that they gave me variances that nobody had gotten in 20yrs in the area to knock it down and redevelop the site. And what seemed was good turned no-go, turned into a nice deal end of day. I sold rights to strip it to a reclamation co., than sold the approved ready to go deal with plans to a builder who completed the redevelopment and made themselves a nice penny also. Everyone won, city was ecstatic, Seller, me, builder, end buyer, following tenants. 

Go where the deal takes you, don't wear blinders, keep your vision open for whatever opportunities present themself, and NEVER invest on hope, facts only, known documented FACTS. 

Hope is a table at the casino. 


James you have helped significantly. Your feedback has given me clarity and your suggestions offered once implemented will mitigate some risks.

I'm waiting on the rent roll and supporting documents for further analysis. If all goes well, I'm building the courage to surrender to the challenge. 

I appreciate the time taken to offer your experience. Every comment makes the BP community stronger!

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @V.G Jason:
Quote from @Venice Victory:
Quote from @V.G Jason:
Quote from @Venice Victory:
Quote from @V.G Jason:
Quote from @Chris Seveney:

$5M

hard money lendin at $10% = $500k a year which is $40k/mo+

if you can make it with $1M that risk is close to betting on a roulette wheel. 


 More.

Assuming she wants net. You're also assuming no defaults, or nothing going awry. And 10% is rich, but fair. Just unlikely you'll allocate all the money as a HML without a super strong network which may be unlikelier than all deals being properly paid on time.


You'll need to invest $8million gross, at 10% gross returns to make $40k/mo net. Likely more to invest, cause returns aren't going to be 10% year over year. 


Thanks I appreciate your contribution. All valid points that help me rule out HML. My intention is not to buy the sellers problem but to provide a solution. If I have a $1M I can be the solution and buyer.

Next up I'll be exploring what would the seller pay for peace of mind?

Well, don't rule out HML. That's flipping to the other side of the spectrum. Chris is a high level note investor, he has that network. Form my understanding or lack of understanding, you're not.

Just don't see it as a prudent way to deploy $8mil in capital if you don't have the network. Maybe allocate $400-600k there? The next thing you'd really want to do is see how you should allocate that $8mil so the amount of disruptions is minimal, some portfolio management basically. 

 Interesting. Can you help me understand how the $8M factors in?

I want to purchase an underperforming asset at a Price of X. Once repositioned the expected CF could be approximately $30K/month, less the debt owed for getting into the deal. Whatever the terms will be made on the $1M, will also decrease that cash flow.

In a perfect & simple world I would pay 8% every year if I I was able to borrow $1M. Yielding 80K a year for allowing me to use their money to fund the deal for 7 years. In year 7 principal will be repaid.

Ideally this would be awesome. Let's hear more about that $8M, although its significantly above my expected offer price and why I should not rule out HML / Chris. It seems I may have misunderstood his comment completely. Betting on a roulette wheel is not something I am familiar with and I am pretty much sure my mind correlated the comment to russian roulette, NOPE, I am good, lol.

Thanks for the opportunity to get clarity.

I am confused.

$8m gross at a 10% return will yield this $40k/mo. $800k/annually less 38% taxes= $496,000 annually=$41k/mo.

I was simply answering what it would take to yield $40k in cash flow monthly, that is all.

To answer your other questions, I don't know what you're buying with $1M that produces gross $30k/mo. Seems rather suspect with a 36% cap rate, and it's imperative to factor in the debt especially in a indefinitely and new normal high debt world. And then the debt service of that $1mil too.

If you paid 8% on the $1m to invest, you wouldn't yield $80k. You'd be paying interest of $80k. The lender wouldn't yield $80k, they'd yield $80k less taxes which is closer to $50k.

Going back to I am confused, I don't understand exactly what you are looking to do or trying to get at. If you're trying to work backwards on how to get to $40k/monthly net, you'll need to invest $8mil up front and aim for a 10% return.  If that's not what you're getting at, what are you trying to ask?


 Thanks 

I now see that you would pay $8M.

I've gathered all the data I needed. Thanks for shedding light on how others operate and what is accepted as the new normal.

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @V.G Jason:
Quote from @Venice Victory:
Quote from @V.G Jason:
Quote from @Chris Seveney:

$5M

hard money lendin at $10% = $500k a year which is $40k/mo+

if you can make it with $1M that risk is close to betting on a roulette wheel. 


 More.

Assuming she wants net. You're also assuming no defaults, or nothing going awry. And 10% is rich, but fair. Just unlikely you'll allocate all the money as a HML without a super strong network which may be unlikelier than all deals being properly paid on time.


You'll need to invest $8million gross, at 10% gross returns to make $40k/mo net. Likely more to invest, cause returns aren't going to be 10% year over year. 


Thanks I appreciate your contribution. All valid points that help me rule out HML. My intention is not to buy the sellers problem but to provide a solution. If I have a $1M I can be the solution and buyer.

Next up I'll be exploring what would the seller pay for peace of mind?

Well, don't rule out HML. That's flipping to the other side of the spectrum. Chris is a high level note investor, he has that network. Form my understanding or lack of understanding, you're not.

Just don't see it as a prudent way to deploy $8mil in capital if you don't have the network. Maybe allocate $400-600k there? The next thing you'd really want to do is see how you should allocate that $8mil so the amount of disruptions is minimal, some portfolio management basically. 

 Interesting. Can you help me understand how the $8M factors in?

I want to purchase an underperforming asset at a Price of X. Once repositioned the expected CF could be approximately $30K/month, less the debt owed for getting into the deal. Whatever the terms will be made on the $1M, will also decrease that cash flow.

In a perfect & simple world I would pay 8% every year if I I was able to borrow $1M. Yielding 80K a year for allowing me to use their money to fund the deal for 7 years. In year 7 principal will be repaid.

Ideally this would be awesome. Let's hear more about that $8M, although its significantly above my expected offer price and why I should not rule out HML / Chris. It seems I may have misunderstood his comment completely. Betting on a roulette wheel is not something I am familiar with and I am pretty much sure my mind correlated the comment to russian roulette, NOPE, I am good, lol.

Thanks for the opportunity to get clarity.

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Venice Victory:

That's it, that is the question!

How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k? Explain.

I really like this question for discussion Venice, but one very major factor left off is at what risk exposure. 

Example; 

I am invested in a fund that does active option plays on Tesla. Most would think it insanely astronomical returns, and it is, but it's also exceptionally high risk. So it's weighted returns. 

Conversely, a new built A class SFR, in A class market of significant growth via a well laid out planned city development, great schools, area people are glamouring to move to, a-class tenants, very very low risk. So in that a much lower rate of return is acceptable given the safety and certainty level of things.

And those factors of risk exposure and weighted returns, drastically change how much capital I'd be comfortable to outlay, for a $40k annual return. 

If were talking the later, I'd be a very happy camper at $6.85m. 

If talking the former, I'd consider up to $600k. 


 Thanks for the feedback and contributions. Not sure if it's because you started with my name but this response makes me feel more safe to share more details.

Its an interesting multifamily that was repositioned to be rented out by bedroom with the majority of the rents being paid by nonprofits. 

There is steady supply of renters, "guaranteed" rent and the organization wants to continue to partner. I'm not sure how the current political impacts this. Current owner says there weren't impacted the last time it shutdown. A motivated seller could say anything to close. Any insight here would be helpful? 

I want happy campers in my network - you've helped reiterate any deal can be good at the right purchase price.

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @V.G Jason:
Quote from @Chris Seveney:

$5M

hard money lendin at $10% = $500k a year which is $40k/mo+

if you can make it with $1M that risk is close to betting on a roulette wheel. 


 More.

Assuming she wants net. You're also assuming no defaults, or nothing going awry. And 10% is rich, but fair. Just unlikely you'll allocate all the money as a HML without a super strong network which may be unlikelier than all deals being properly paid on time.


You'll need to invest $8million gross, at 10% gross returns to make $40k/mo net. Likely more to invest, cause returns aren't going to be 10% year over year. 


Thanks I appreciate your contribution. All valid points that help me rule out HML. My intention is not to buy the sellers problem but to provide a solution. If I have a $1M I can be the solution and buyer.

Next up I'll be exploring what would the seller pay for peace of mind?

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Chris Seveney:

$5M

hard money lendin at $10% = $500k a year which is $40k/mo+

if you can make it with $1M that risk is close to betting on a roulette wheel. 


 Thanks - yes too risky for me. I'm thinking that's how the seller ended up motivated to sell. I'm under the impression that if a viable solution is  presented with a clear path for the seller to exit this would be a Win - Win.

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Henry Clark:
Quote from @Venice Victory:
Quote from @Henry Clark:
Quote from @Venice Victory:
Quote from @Henry Clark:

OP posters ask similar questions frequently.  Do you have $4mm to $20mm you can access?  Let’s say your 25% of that so you personally have to come up with$1mm to $5mm.  If you have that much great.  If you don’t you should choose a different question.  Based on your response I can give you some paths.  Whether your at $0 or $10mm of personal cash to start with.  


 I like to ask questions to better understand other perspectives. I appreciate learning from others. 

I'm currently underwriting a deal that seemed too good to be true. I'm here to help gather the data  to evaluate if it in fact is a good deal. 

I need only $1M to get access to that monthly $40K. Any ideas on how to get access to the $1M? My resources and skin in the game is being allocated to the remaining balance of X purchase price.

What path do you recommend in this scenario?


 Problem is there are to many investment types.  For example we do self storage.  With $1mm cash we can do 3 locations netting $40,000 before income tax per month.   “BUT” up to 60% occupancy all of the cash flow goes to the bank for PI which is good.   

But your question what do you mean by $40,000 per month.   Are you trying to replace your salary then you can’t do it.  Unless the $1mm is 100% of the investment possibly.


No one can give you a good answer without more details.  


The $1M is the remaining balance of the purchase price. Do you have a list of recommended lenders?

I'm not even sure how salary got introduced into this scenario but I'd prefer to discuss solutions and explore ways to get to the objective. 

You don’t know what you don’t know.  You’re giving very limited information which forces people responding to cover unnecessary points. 

You’re a Project leader. The same skillsets apply to your question. You will waste both your effort and others without a clear post.  


 You do not need to give out the address or contacts.  

But you do need to give the deal items for worthwhile info.  

You just added another crumb of information which can mean anything.  $1mm is the remainder of the investment.  You want to know a lender.  Everyone will give you wrong information wasting their time and yours.  

Is it a restaurant. SFH. Bowling alley. 15 unit MFH. Etc.

Why are you giving crumbs of information out versus detailing the deal?  


There is no deal under contract, I'm exploring options so that I'm comfortable with pursuing an offer. I have an opportunity to buy low and since the cash flow is great, I'd prefer not to sell and hold. Which means I'm evaluating the possible exit strategies for a long-term hold. 

I'm here on the forum to better understand - how others would navigate a similar scenario.

I guess I'm still shopping for the ingredients to determine if there is a 🍞 of bread and if I should even attempt to bake it. What I do know is I don't plan to leave any crumbs 😂

I also am aware of laws that say I shouldn't say things like, "I'm offering 8% return to someone who has the liquidity/resources", if they are not friends or family. Currently accepting applications for friends and family because teamwork makes our dreams work.

Even then, that statement has narrowed the possible solutions. 

Considering that another idea is to partner up with the seller, revitalize/ reposition as business or organization. That pathway could open up traditional bank financing but I'm not sure. Maybe play matchmaker to an organization that serves this population.

Thanks for all your help. 

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Henry Clark:
Quote from @Venice Victory:
Quote from @Henry Clark:

OP posters ask similar questions frequently.  Do you have $4mm to $20mm you can access?  Let’s say your 25% of that so you personally have to come up with$1mm to $5mm.  If you have that much great.  If you don’t you should choose a different question.  Based on your response I can give you some paths.  Whether your at $0 or $10mm of personal cash to start with.  


 I like to ask questions to better understand other perspectives. I appreciate learning from others. 

I'm currently underwriting a deal that seemed too good to be true. I'm here to help gather the data  to evaluate if it in fact is a good deal. 

I need only $1M to get access to that monthly $40K. Any ideas on how to get access to the $1M? My resources and skin in the game is being allocated to the remaining balance of X purchase price.

What path do you recommend in this scenario?


 Problem is there are to many investment types.  For example we do self storage.  With $1mm cash we can do 3 locations netting $40,000 before income tax per month.   “BUT” up to 60% occupancy all of the cash flow goes to the bank for PI which is good.   

But your question what do you mean by $40,000 per month.   Are you trying to replace your salary then you can’t do it.  Unless the $1mm is 100% of the investment possibly.


No one can give you a good answer without more details.  


The $1M is the remaining balance of the purchase price. Do you have a list of recommended lenders?

I'm not even sure how salary got introduced into this scenario but I'd prefer to discuss solutions and explore ways to get to the objective. 

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Eric James:
Quote from @Venice Victory:
Quote from @Henry Clark:

OP posters ask similar questions frequently.  Do you have $4mm to $20mm you can access?  Let’s say your 25% of that so you personally have to come up with$1mm to $5mm.  If you have that much great.  If you don’t you should choose a different question.  Based on your response I can give you some paths.  Whether your at $0 or $10mm of personal cash to start with.  


 I like to ask questions to better understand other perspectives. I appreciate learning from others. 

I'm currently underwriting a deal that seemed too good to be true. I'm here to help gather the data  to evaluate if it in fact is a good deal. 

I need only $1M to get access to that monthly $40K. Any ideas on how to get access to the $1M? My resources and skin in the game is being allocated to the remaining balance of X purchase price.

What path do you recommend in this scenario?


 You mean you want someo to give you the money needed for a purchase and you'll handle the rest?


I'm exploring ideas on how to gather the remainder needed $1M of the purchase price. Yes the plan is to reposition the asset to earn the $40K. Currently about $27K. Maybe 9 weeks to get it fully occupied.

All money goes towards the deal and purchase price. I'd like to lock this up under contract but need to identify the best exit strategy considering I'd like to hold onto the property/operation. 

Seller is pretty motivated and flexible to the reposition/partnership. I'm not sure how to protect my value add strategy if in partnership and would prefer to outright own.

Post: How much would you spend today for a monthly cash flow of $40k?

Venice VictoryPosted
  • Specialist
  • Austin TX; Boston, MA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Henry Clark:

OP posters ask similar questions frequently.  Do you have $4mm to $20mm you can access?  Let’s say your 25% of that so you personally have to come up with$1mm to $5mm.  If you have that much great.  If you don’t you should choose a different question.  Based on your response I can give you some paths.  Whether your at $0 or $10mm of personal cash to start with.  


 I like to ask questions to better understand other perspectives. I appreciate learning from others. 

I'm currently underwriting a deal that seemed too good to be true. I'm here to help gather the data  to evaluate if it in fact is a good deal. 

I need only $1M to get access to that monthly $40K. Any ideas on how to get access to the $1M? My resources and skin in the game is being allocated to the remaining balance of X purchase price.

What path do you recommend in this scenario?