Hi Jennifer,
I currently house hack in Montclair, and overall I'd say this looks like a decent deal (definitely much cheaper than I was able to get out here!). In addition to the above comments on refinancing, some thoughts from me:
- I noticed it's listed as a 4/2; I assume your plan is to market the office as the 3rd bedroom to get a nice bump in the rent. I think that could work well, I just suggest you double-check that you don't run into any problems, as I see this is the most critical assumption in your analysis. I'm not sure how Certificate's of Occupancy (COs) work in Morristown (maybe someone that owns there can chime in), but I would try to verify that you won't run into any problems renting as a 3bd. Also, check your comp set for rents to try and gauge how your 3rd bedroom compares to others; if most other places have a "full" 3 bedrooms with closets, it may / may not impact your rent.
- Besides that, regarding your cost projections: closing costs may be a bit high (depending on whether you are including pre-paids and such in that number) but overall I think it is a nice conservative estimate; lawn/snow removal: I think that is actually a good estimate if you are having a company do it, doesn't look like a huge property so should be ok; Insurance - I think $2k is again a safe estimate, hopefully a little cheaper!
- In terms of whether this specific property is a "good property for a first investment", it really depends on what your investment goals (and alternatives) are. That said, if your rent and financing assumptions are correct, this seems like a good way to get started with rentals in Morristown.