Thanks for the input guys. The reason I am living next door is because as a recent college grad the only way I could get it done before the tax credit expired (credit was more than my DP) was to go FHA, and thus OO.
I think most of the stuff that I have done 'wrong' so far is due to thinking about what I would want in a unit I lived in v. what I need to do to get it rented. That is definitely the case with the W/D and paint. I painted every room and closet, and re-painted all the trim and doors (I used the 5 gals. of dutch boy antique white throughout). The main issue with the paint was that the rooms were bright blue, pink, yellow, etc. and thus took a ton to cover well.
I like the 2 year lease is a great idea, and I used a one year based on the same rationale. My only hesitancy to go longer in this case is that since living next door, I want an out in case they are not good neighbors but also not evictable. I will definiely give that a try though once I move out and it becomes a full rental.
On a mostly unrelated note, I just had the inspection (aced it) and though I am pretty new to this, I think that based on some info i got from the inspector there might be a possible deal on another property nearby that I would like to own, so if you have a chance check out my post in the deal analysis section and let me know if you have any ideas, Thanks again.