@Mike D'Arrigo, Thanks for the reply. I bought via an exchange May 2019, so fortunately there is equity and good cashflow as a result of that (and going solo vs. our partnership situation on the property we sold here).
I am researching both areas, and agree that Phoenix is a very competitive market vs. Lafayette. Though in talking with a realtor there, I'm finding out that for their market, things are also very tight in terms of inventory. I'm just trying to weigh these factors:
1. The work it will take to put a team/system to find value add properties in Phoenix to get the bigger dollar appreciation and slightly above average cash flow.
2. How many units do I need to purchase in Indiana for the cashflow to make it worthwhile and forego the appreciation in Phoenix?
3. And what's the difference in time to reach my goals for appreciation vs. cashflow.
Is my thinking out of the norm to think that, with the Phoenix metro area being so much bigger, there are more opportunities to still find a strategy that works?