Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Thomas O'Donnell

Thomas O'Donnell has started 92 posts and replied 230 times.

Post: Newbie looking to house hacking a small multifamily in Austin, TX

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188
Quote from @Thomas O'Donnell:

Hey Ben,

I'm a new investor as well having just purchased my first duplex to house-hack in October 2022. My opinion is to not overthink it on your first property. The main thing is to get started. However, due to the current market that we are in, and with a lot of uncertainty, I would definitely stay conservative. Look for something in a nice neighborhood, that might not cash flow from the very start, but has a great chance to cash-flow in the near future once you move out and raise rents. Buying in the right area is key if you're looking to hold long-term.

Chances are in a market like Austin, it is going to be hard to cash-flow at the beginning with an FHA loan (due to the lower down payment), and better neighborhoods usually cash-flow less but appreciate more. Interest rates are not certain to fall within the next year and may stay about the same or even increase a tiny bit more. I would definitely pad any rehab estimates and budget for more than you think they will come out to. Using an FHA 203k loan may be an option for you as it allows you to pair the rehab costs with the first-time home buyer loan (though it can be a tricky process).

Make sure you are also negotiating on your purchase. Buyers now have the power to offer less and put in more contingencies like inspections. Some sellers are still trying to sell their properties at peak 2021/2022 prices. Offer knowing that the market could slide a bit and make sure you have a cushion for yourself. One of the things I negotiated that helped a lot was for the seller to pay all closing costs. If you can get this done, it also leaves you with more capital to use towards any necessary renovations, or to pay the full mortgage on your own until you can get a tenant in there. 

I wish you the best of luck and I hope everything works out for you, happy investing!


 P.S. I was born and raised in Santa Clara, and moved out to Columbus, OH to begin my investing journey. 

Post: Newbie looking to house hacking a small multifamily in Austin, TX

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188

Hey Ben,

I'm a new investor as well having just purchased my first duplex to house-hack in October 2022. My opinion is to not overthink it on your first property. The main thing is to get started. However, due to the current market that we are in, and with a lot of uncertainty, I would definitely stay conservative. Look for something in a nice neighborhood, that might not cash flow from the very start, but has a great chance to cash-flow in the near future once you move out and raise rents. Buying in the right area is key if you're looking to hold long-term.

Chances are in a market like Austin, it is going to be hard to cash-flow at the beginning with an FHA loan (due to the lower down payment), and better neighborhoods usually cash-flow less but appreciate more. Interest rates are not certain to fall within the next year and may stay about the same or even increase a tiny bit more. I would definitely pad any rehab estimates and budget for more than you think they will come out to. Using an FHA 203k loan may be an option for you as it allows you to pair the rehab costs with the first-time home buyer loan (though it can be a tricky process).

Make sure you are also negotiating on your purchase. Buyers now have the power to offer less and put in more contingencies like inspections. Some sellers are still trying to sell their properties at peak 2021/2022 prices. Offer knowing that the market could slide a bit and make sure you have a cushion for yourself. One of the things I negotiated that helped a lot was for the seller to pay all closing costs. If you can get this done, it also leaves you with more capital to use towards any necessary renovations, or to pay the full mortgage on your own until you can get a tenant in there. 

I wish you the best of luck and I hope everything works out for you, happy investing!

Post: No Pet Policy & Service Animals

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188

I was messaged by someone interested in renting my duplex. Not only are they looking to move in “immediately” (red flag) but they also stated they have a service dog and another small dog. My listing and lease both say no pets… although I know you can’t really deny someone based on having a service animal. How should I go about this situation in a way where I don’t violate any fair housing laws? Any advice is welcome, thanks!

Post: I Received a Message From Corporate Housing for My Rental Unit

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188

I am definitely interested in getting more information from them as it doesn’t hurt. What kinds of questions should I be looking to ask them? 

Post: I Received a Message From Corporate Housing for My Rental Unit

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188

Hello all,

I recently received a message from a corporate housing company for my vacant rental unit. The message reads as followed

"Hi, My name is Zach, and I run a corporate housing company called Zillycon Capital. We have been in business for 5 years and are becoming the premier name in corporate leasing. We are seeking high quality vacant units to rent to our corporate travelers (stays of 90 days or less). If your unit qualifies, we can sign 1-4 year leases for your property or as many units as you have available. With Zillycon, you get the highest quality tenants, free property management, which includes weekly cleaning/minor maintenance, and a host of security features. I'd love to continue this conversation and see if we are a good fit. Looking forward to hearing back. Zach https://zillyconrentals.com/ho... zillyconrentals.com Home | Zillycon Rentals"

However, I am not sure if this is legit or how it truly works. It seems like its basically a medium term rental arbitrage situation. How should I go about this? I'm currently having trouble getting my unit rented, but it also is completely unfurnished making it hard to do medium-term. Should I entertain this idea at all? If so, why? If not, why not? Thanks! (P.S. I live about a mile from Children's Hospital)

Post: Applicant With a Co-Signer

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188

How do you go about having an applicant with a co-signer? I might end up having one and I am just wondering if I have them both fill out an application, or if they are both put on the lease. Sorry for what might be a "dumb question".

Post: Looking for Some Advice on My Current Real Estate Situation

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188

Thank you so much for all of this great input! I really appreciate all the responses.

Post: Looking for Some Advice on My Current Real Estate Situation

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188
Quote from @Diya Wahi:
Quote from @Thomas O'Donnell:
Quote from @Brett Merrill:

Hi @Thomas O'Donnell. Don't get too discouraged, most have been in a similar situation to this or another completely different situation that is just as challenging. I think you are being smart by screening your tenants thoroughly. You certainly do not want to rush the wrong people into your unit to collect a little cash as this can turn into a much more expensive expense down the road. However, I do want to make sure that you are not over screening with too strict of criteria. Do you mind sharing with us how you are currently marketing the property and what your current criteria is? I have looked into Columbus and it seems to be a strong enough rental market so there is something that needs to be tweaked. Also, does the property have any other ability to produce rent such as a garage for storage or do you have an extra room in your unit that a friend or family could rent? Hope this helps. 


 So it’s a 3bed 1bath duplex, and market rents are 1200-1500 in the area. I am asking $1300 water included because it isn’t split. My basic criteria is 600+ credit, no smoking, no evictions, renter’s insurance and income 3x the rent. Many leads that I have got have been asking for section 8 but I have not gone through that process to get certified yet. It has an unfinished basement that can be used for storage. I moved her from California back in late July and did not know anyone in the area which rules out renting to a family member or friend. 


 Hi Thomas! It sounds like this is potentially tough time of the year regarding weather to find great tenants. Out of curiosity, can your unit be rented as a mid-term rental for traveling nurses or PAs? Columbus is a college town. How about professionals related to the university to temporary trips? Or Airbnb? Since this may be the wrong time of year for a long term tenant, could another option be better band aid until the Spring/Summer?


 I do not have the funds to furnish the whole unit, or I would have thought about doing mid-term since I am less than a mile from Nationwide Children's Hospital. I am about 15-20min south of the college so renting to students wouldn't make much sense. 

Post: Looking for Some Advice on My Current Real Estate Situation

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188
Quote from @Owen Dashner:

Where is your property located and what advertising methods are you using?  Are you doing Zillow, Facebook Marketplace, etc?


 Zillow, FB marketplace, Avail, apartments.com etc

Post: Looking for Some Advice on My Current Real Estate Situation

Thomas O'DonnellPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Columbus, OH
  • Posts 231
  • Votes 188
Quote from @Brett Merrill:

Hi @Thomas O'Donnell. Don't get too discouraged, most have been in a similar situation to this or another completely different situation that is just as challenging. I think you are being smart by screening your tenants thoroughly. You certainly do not want to rush the wrong people into your unit to collect a little cash as this can turn into a much more expensive expense down the road. However, I do want to make sure that you are not over screening with too strict of criteria. Do you mind sharing with us how you are currently marketing the property and what your current criteria is? I have looked into Columbus and it seems to be a strong enough rental market so there is something that needs to be tweaked. Also, does the property have any other ability to produce rent such as a garage for storage or do you have an extra room in your unit that a friend or family could rent? Hope this helps. 


 So it’s a 3bed 1bath duplex, and market rents are 1200-1500 in the area. I am asking $1300 water included because it isn’t split. My basic criteria is 600+ credit, no smoking, no evictions, renter’s insurance and income 3x the rent. Many leads that I have got have been asking for section 8 but I have not gone through that process to get certified yet. It has an unfinished basement that can be used for storage. I moved her from California back in late July and did not know anyone in the area which rules out renting to a family member or friend.