Hi @Natalie Schanne,
You've given me a lot to think about and I've certainly given it plenty of consideration over the weekend.
Part of looking into South Jersey was the taxes, and the other part was price. I just wasn't finding anything in my price range around here (< 290k, looking for 1-2 months) and so I thought that what I was searching for was unattainable.
What you mentioned about your in-laws shook me up a bit.
I also thought long and hard about the reality of being a first-time landlord and living an hour away from the property. I've heard many people (like Brandon Turner!) say that tenants tend not to take care of the property as much as they would if they know they landlord is present. At a company retreat I attended just a week ago, our CEO was speaking about ownership and the entrepreneurial spirit and he shared the quote, "the best fertilizer for a vineyard is the owner's footsteps."
So this weekend I went back on Trulia and looked in my vicinity.. and I was in shock when I saw how many new properties were on the market in a matter of a few weeks.
If it weren't for your post I would have given up searching around here. And newbie lesson learned— listings come and go fast!
Thanks so much for sharing your insight.
PS- I have 2 viewings scheduled for late this week; one in Linden (2 units) and one in Bloomfield on the Montclair border (3 units).