Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Sam Bhattacharya

Sam Bhattacharya has started 6 posts and replied 48 times.

Post: Why BRRRR is dead....

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31
Quote from @Tyler Haanen:
Quote from @Sam Bhattacharya:
Quote from @Marcus Auerbach:

The great days of BRRRR are gone. 

The compression of inventory over the last 10 years has gradually restricted the discounts on the buying side. If inventory is low and competition is high, properties in poor condition will sell for almost as much as properties in great condition. For a good BRRRR you need at least half off ARV, that means buying a 200k home for 100k and fixing it for under 50, that is just not realistic anymore. It will sell for 185k as is to a first time home buyer with a handy family, who has no idea how much time and money it will eventually cost him to complete a full gut rehab.

The thing I don't understand about this is that you can easily find properties in the Milwaukee area for less than $100,000 on zillow and other web sites.  I've seen some for as low as $40,000.

Do real estate agents just not consider these properties?

Anything at that price point most likely is in a C- to D Neighborhood. Milwaukee is very block to block sensitive, making it extra important to have someone who has lived in the city long enough to know which ones are great, good, fair, and downright bad. I have lived here for almost 20 years and I still learn more every time I drive around. 

That's kind of what I'm getting from talking to agents in different markets in the midwest.  

So, the question is if these properties are not good for BRRRR, then can they still be good for flipping? Can you expect the ARV to be around double the purchase price, or is it still a no go for that purpose too?

Somebody is obviously buying these $40,000 to $50,000 properties in midwest cities.  Actually, this is true of Baltimore too. So, who is buying them if not investors?

Post: Why BRRRR is dead....

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31
Quote from @Marcus Auerbach:

The great days of BRRRR are gone. 

The compression of inventory over the last 10 years has gradually restricted the discounts on the buying side. If inventory is low and competition is high, properties in poor condition will sell for almost as much as properties in great condition. For a good BRRRR you need at least half off ARV, that means buying a 200k home for 100k and fixing it for under 50, that is just not realistic anymore. It will sell for 185k as is to a first time home buyer with a handy family, who has no idea how much time and money it will eventually cost him to complete a full gut rehab.

The thing I don't understand about this is that you can easily find properties in the Milwaukee area for less than $100,000 on zillow and other web sites.  I've seen some for as low as $40,000.

Do real estate agents just not consider these properties?

Post: Hot/Growing Real Estate Markets for Investment Real Estate

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31
Quote from @Alex Olson:

@Dominic Pizzi Yes Kansas City is a great market for real estate investors. Appreciation is here as well as cash flow. I can show some really good examples of what some outside and inside investors have been able to accomplish, even with the rising interest rates.

Can you buy a house for $75,000, rehab for $25,000, and get an ARV of $150,000?

Post: Is this a good rental property?

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31
Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:

The answer is no...sorry.  This is a math problem.

First, the only cost to the REI for a property is the cash they spend. By paying all cash, you have paid full price. If a property cash flows, then the tenant is paying for the rest...not you...and they do it without question. You just took over their job, and are NOT saving money in the process. You are losing money because of it. Also, like any business, you don't start to make a profit until you recover all of your cost, so, with that in mind,...

Here are your numbers buying all cash:
1 - Your cost (cash) = $160k
2 - Your cash flow per year = $11,200
3 - Number of years to recover your cost and start to make a profit = over 14

Here are your numbers buying with a 20% DP
:
1 - Your cost (cash) = $32k
2 - Your cash flow per year = $1080 (assuming 30 years/7% interest)
3 - Number of years to recover your cost and start to make a profit = over 30...so even worse.

I won't touch a property unless my cost recovery time is less than 6 years.

For a 20% DP, the loan amount = $128,000

Mortgage payment based on 30 years/7% interest = $852 per month or $10,224 per year.  

Cash flow required for a cost recovery time of 6 years = $444 per month or $5,333 per year

Rent = Cash flow + Mortgage payment + Expenses

Therefore, Rent = $444 + $852 + $660 = $1,956 per month

1,956/160,000 = 1.22%

So, are you saying a rental property isn't worth it unless it meets a 1.22% rule?

Post: What do investors do during recessions?

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31
Quote from @Scott Mac:

Some get crushed.

Some make money.

Some sit still.

Some hunt and buy good deals.

How exactly do investors get “crushed”when house prices go down?  I wasn’t investing in 2008, but I did own a primary residence.  

The value of the house went below the mortgage balance for a number of years.   I just kept making the mortgage payment every month as usual.  Nothing changed. 

Post: Still BRRRR'ing in this market?

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31
Quote from @Nate Sanow:

Here’s my thing on brrrr and why I think it’s amazing no matter what a market is doing.  

I can borrow someone else’s money to buy an asset. 

I can use someone else’s time to renovate it. And likely, someone else’s money to pay for the renovation. 

I can use someone else’s money to fully pay off the first person I borrowed from. 

I can then get a new loan, that someone else / the tenant will pay off for me. 

I mean really, I feel like Christmas morning after every successful brrr. Like a spoiled little kid. It’s amazing. 

No matter what a market does, apart from an actual nuclear, apocalyptic meltdown collapse where Zombies are eating investors alive, I’m all for another 1000 brrrrs. 


 Hi Nate, thanks for this breakdown.  How do you use someone else's money to pay off the first person you borrowed from?

Post: How to become a private lender?

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31
Quote from @Klavish Faraj:

So there aren't any companies that vet lendees and make the process more smoother and protect everyone involved?

Typically, an attorney is involved in setting up the relationship between a private lender and a real estate investor.  A property is secured by a note and deed of trust which give the lender the right to foreclose if the investor doesn't fulfill their end of the relationship.

Also, an insurance certificate can be made out to the lender so they are protected with insurance in case of a total loss.

Post: Phoenix is #2 !!! - - - - - (Austin is #1 )

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31

According to zillow, one of my houses is down 7% from its peak value that was hit around May.  The other is down 1%.

I am in the DC area.

Post: GET OFF THE COMPUTER

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31
Quote from @Luka Milicevic:

I got started in RE 9 years ago and EVERYONE around me told me not to. "market is too hot" 

A few years in I was told there are better ways to make money since I have "nothing to show for it"

Today....they are silent.

Taking massive action is the ONLY way to succeed. APPLIED knowledge is power. 

The market was hot in 2013?

What country was this in?

Post: buy one rental property cash or multiple properties with mortgage

Sam BhattacharyaPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Damascus, MD
  • Posts 49
  • Votes 31

If I had $1 million lying around to invest in real estate, then I would buy way more than just 2-3 properties with it.

More like several multi-family properties.