Originally posted by @Andrew Powers:
Have you run numbers with PMI and low down payment vs no PMI and high down payment? Depending on how much your PMI would be, your required margins, and your long term strategy... it can make sense to pay the PMI if your out of pocket cost is low and your returns are acceptable.
Given the market uncertainty in the near future and for you just starting out, it is often recommended to conserve cash.
My required margins are 12% or more COC. At least $100 per door cash flow on duplex, $200 per door cash flow on single family. My long term strategy is buy and hold single family and multifamily rental properties.
Here are the numbers:
with PMI and low down payment (house hacking)
Purchase price: $170,000 | Closing cost: $2,500 | Down payment: $10,000 (5.9%) | PMI: $67
COC: 16.56% | Cash flow: $310 | NOI: $985
no PMI and high down payment
Purchase price: $170,000 | Closing cost: $2,500 | Down payment: $34,000 (20%)
COC: 7.70% with management fee (10%) | Cash flow: $298 | NOI: $871
COC: 12.36% without management fee| Cash flow: $478 | NOI: $1052