@Bill B. and @Shawn McCormick thanks for taking the time to answer my question and provide your insights. I appreciate and avlue the feedback you've provided. For what it's worth, I did Google search and search the site for this question, but only got irrelevant results. Apparently I'm not searching for the right thing.
I'm aware banks won't recognize the value of the rental income because there is no lease, so my target buyer would be an investor or investment firm looking to pay cash. It sounds like from Shawn's experience that something like that doesn't happen currently, so I'd be trailblazing, if I could get it to work. I have to admit that's a solid deterrent, by itself. I might have a better shot at it if build a portfolio of properties and sell them all together as a business.
@Bill B. for context, the home is in a dedicated STR community, so it's safe to say there's a 0% chance of running into troubles like you mentioned in Oahu or Las Vegas.
Also, like I said, those numbers are 100% made up on the spot. I'd need to sit down and figure out my real numbers over the last 3 years. Out of curiosity, from your perspective, what ROI (or other relevant KPI) would it need to have to grab an investor's attention?