Chase and Mathew,
Thanks for the quick responses! Yes the argument for both sides is very real and makes for a hard decision.
Honestly, I'd love to hang onto this duplex as a long term investment. That was the goal from the very beginning. But if I were to sell, I'd definitely use the money to re-invest in a 1031 for more rental properties, just not in the Portland area as I believe it's now over priced, but in other states.
The problem that I'm wrestling in my head with is if this hot Portland market currently is in a bubble or not. If rent and property values stay the same or slightly rise for the next few years, I would not sell it. But I feel like the hot market bubble may burst soon and home values and rent may decrease and I'll lose out on years worth of profits that I could easily take right now. Losing out on potential profits is my biggest fear and could become a big regret.
Looking ahead, what are your personal opinions on the Portland market for the next few years? Does it keep heating up or cooling down?