Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Sebastian Villacis M.

Sebastian Villacis M. has started 3 posts and replied 21 times.

@Sarah Weaver, Thank you for your response. I will give it a shot.

Also, thank you for publishing 30 Day Stay. I pre-ordered, waited for the book around 3 weeks, and finished reading it 5 days after receiving it. You and Zeona did a really good job. I was surprised by how fast you scaled up using creative financing. Congrats and keep up the good work.

@Colleen F. your feedback is much appreciated. Any experience providing housing to travel nurses in Cleveland? It will be nice learning more from you.

@Shane Kelly Thank you so much for your feedback. It is my understanding that the agency the got hired by the one that takes care of housing if the nurse wants to; otherwise, housing is decided by the nurses themselves  or what is referred as stepend. Hospitals are not involved in housing from what I knew. Maybe Cleveland works a bit different.

Hi BP Community,

I am interested in investing in Cleveland, OH, around the Wakefield/Detroit Shoreway/Edgewater area to be more specific. I want to buy a duplex and have each unit serve as MTR for traveling nurses or other professionals coming to Cleveland. My only concern is if Cleveland is actually attracting traveling nurses. I understand Cleveland has some of the best and biggest hospitals in the nation but after reading statistics from Furnished Finder it seems like the demand of traveling nurses does not reflect the current growth and magnitude of the healthcare industry in the area for whatever reason. I may be wrong that is why I created this post to see if maybe I can get advice from an investor who has done this already and seen the results. 

Thank you in advance for your valuable feedback.

Hi All,

I was reading this interesting forum since it goes hand-in-hand to my future investment properties. As a quick update to all, it is important to mention that Fairfax County now allows ALUs (additional living units) as long as it meets some requirements (found here: https://www.fairfaxcounty.gov/...). I am still a bit uncertain if I could get around getting a permit for the ALU countertop burner since we DO want to have privacy and not share spaces with the prospect tenants. If gas stove is provided, I believe building and fire code gets involved and I might have to fire rate walls, etc. I want to know if somebody who knows about this code and if there is a way around it.

Thank you all.

Post: PMI and down payment options

Sebastian Villacis M.Posted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Nicholas Coulter:

@Sebastian Villacis M. I always say pay the PMI monthly. Its normally very low with a 5% down conventional loan and if you add an ADU you might very well cover the 20% LTV with the additional value you forced on the home. If you can afford the payment comfortably use 5% and take the other 5 and start your ADU process. I think youll find the additional 5% down wont make too much head way on your monthly PITI.


 Hey @Nicholas Coulter,

Your advice is very much appreciated. 5% down is definitely in our plans. Also, the ADU idea is based on a space inside the property that has to be somehow ready and in indeed of very minor additions and updates which I don't know if will force the equity to reach 20%. However, you made a very point. Also, our credit is very good which will help us lock a low PMI rate I guess. The fact that 5% down sounds so good now is that it leaves us with extra cash for our next deal. I believe NoVA is all about home appreciation in the long term which kind of matches our idea of buy and hold.

Thanks.

Post: PMI and down payment options

Sebastian Villacis M.Posted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Joaquin Camarasa:

Hey Sebastian,

Airbnb is challenging in Fairfax county as you can't rent out your property as a short term rental for more than 60 days a year. Many investors including myself use mid term rentals which are considered more than 30+ days. Typically traveling workers like nurses or government contractors use those. You can charge 30% - 40% more than with a long term rental.

I personally prefer to use as less cash as possible when buying a property you should be able to put 3% down on your first property. 

I'll be happy to chat if you have any questions. 

Hi @Joaquin Camarasa

You are 100% correct. I didn't realize the obstacles there are for investors in NoVA. I guess I was so focused on forcing my house-hack strategy to work in a market where either rents can't keep up with appreciation or countys' restrictions on STRRs. Begginers like me can benefit a lot from experienced investors like yourself who know the area's pros and cons when it comes down to investing. That being said, which investment strategies do you consider work best in the NoVA market considering all the pros/cons that this area has? I guess one of them is the mid-term rentals and my wife, who's a nurse, has told me so much about traveling nurses but I didn't really consider that option until now. 

We are not limited to the strategy we can use to start investing and are rather very open to listen and learn as we go. We just want to make sure that we step into the market with a strategy that fits perfectly the characteristics of the area.

Would be very happy to chat with you and get more advice.

thanks

Post: PMI and down payment options

Sebastian Villacis M.Posted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Derek Brickley:

Hi Sebastian!

A few people have responded about the PMI and I absolutely would agree with them. As a househack and starting your real estate journey, ask yourself if you are seeking cashflow or appreciation. If your main goal is to decrease your monthly expenses, then if you have the extra money to buy it out that would be the best way to do so. If you don't mind paying more each month, you could put that money elsewhere and maybe make more from it! I would say it is important to consider the opportunity cost of your choices and look over your goals.

With respect to the downpayment, I think again weighing your goals is important. The best bet is to probably discuss this with a loan officer who (hopefully) can give you more information about the exact costs. I'm not sure what your local market (Reston, Sterling, Herndon) is like, but certain markets are in a position where they may see housing prices decrease in the coming months. Putting 10% down may give you more of a cushion against this and again (if your goal is cashflow) you would have a lower payment all around with your PITI and PMI. On the otherhand, putting 5% down frees up more of your capital for other investments (perhaps adding the ADU) which would generate more income in the long run.


So no straightforward answer, but I would strongly reflect on your goals and your willingness to accept risk and decide with those in mind!


 Hi Derek,

You are absolutely right. Your feedback is much appreciated. I just wanted to know what house hackers usually do in regards to PMI (kind of a rule of thumb), but I guess there is not rule of thumb in this case since everyone's goals are different. Thank you again.

Post: PMI and down payment options

Sebastian Villacis M.Posted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Sebastian Villacis M.:

Hi BB community,

I'm new here and so excited to join this amazing community. My wife and I are 6-7 months out from getting our first investment property. We have a beautiful 9 month old baby girl which makes the house hack approach a bit more challenging but we are hopeful everything works out. We want to get a single family house in the Reston, Sterling, Herndon area in the 500k-600k ballpark where we can add an accessory dwelling unit that will be rented out (Airbnb or long term rental TBD). Our goal is really to stay in this first property for a year before we get our second one and house hack again. Based on this goal, our questions are on the financing part of the deal: 

1. For PMI, will it make sense to buy it out or to pay it monthly. The reason I'm asking this is because even though we want to buy and hold our properties and just rent them as we move to our next deals, the monthly PMI payment will still affect our expenses. I've heard that buying out PMI when you want to stay in the house for s long time will make sense but I don't know if that will still apply for the house hack idea considering we don't want to sell our properties so our portfolio grows as we go.

2. We have the chance to put 10% but watching lots of the BB videos we saw that the best (or most?) financing option is 5% down. I guess this question goes hand in hand with the first one since 5% down will mean a longer and higher PMI. Which rate will be better for the approach we want to take.

Thank you so much to everyone for being part of this post. We are so so excited and happy for being part of the BB community.

 @Sebastian Villacis M.    The math generally pencils out that buying out of mortgage insurance only makes sense if you only expect to own the house (or loan) for just a few years.  So, if you expect to own the house for a long time it is actually better to have MI because as mentioned above you have the opportunity to eventually drop the MI.  If you buy out either with upfront cash or by taking a higher rate you are stuck with that outcome.

Also, assuming you have good credit MI rates have really come down over the last few years. and not all lenders have the same MI rates so just like it makes sense to shop for the best interest rate, you also want to  compare MI. I know our MI is often much cheaper then other lenders when compared. 

 Hi @Jay Hurst thank you so much for your response. As explained in my response to @Ika Sargeant, both options, buyout and monthly, are for the same period of time (at 20% equity PMI is removed). The only difference is that buyout is "cheaper" since it would be paid upfront. It is good to know that PMI rates have decreased for good credit which is our case. Thank you so much again for your input.

Post: PMI and down payment options

Sebastian Villacis M.Posted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Ika Sargeant:

@Sebastian Villacis M. So if you pay it up front, does that mean you have opted to pay all of it and bet that the prices would not rise well enough to bump your equity? Because PMI should go away once you reach 20% equity. The other reason I am thinking you, aren't you trying to hold on to your cash. Consider what is beneficial to you, the money you pay now or later. I would suggest you talk to mortgage people so they can show you what type of results would paying up front yield vs paying over time. Congrats on your venture.

per

 Hi @Ika Sargeant thank you so much for your response. So based on my discussion with one of the potential lenders I will pick for our future investment property, the real difference between buying it out than paying it in a monthly basis is that when you buy it out the lump sum is smaller than if you were to add up the monthly PMI I would have paid until meeting the 20% equity. The important factor here is that both options take into consideration the same time frame before meeting the 20% equity requirement. If that is the perspective, then my intuition tells me that buying it out makes more sense because I am basically paying a smaller amount than the total monthly option. However, I am not entirely sure if I am missing any other important deciding factors.