I'm in the position where I will soon either buy another rental property, resulting in $500/month cash flow, or pay off the balance of a second mortgage which would also result in $500/month additional cash flow. Both result in the same cash flow increase for me. If I get another rental though, I have to deal with having another tenant and all that goes with it. However, I'd also get them to build equity in that new investment property for me in addition to the $500/month cash flow. On the other hand, just paying off that second mortgage is an easy, simple way to increase my cash flow. It has around $9,800 left. So I can pay $9,800 to pay that off and increase my cash flow by $500/month, or I could get a new rental property putting $30k down, $10k closing costs, deal with tenant issues, building issues, etc., for that same $500/month increase in cash flow.
It seems like the better choice would be to just pay off that second mortgage. Or am I missing something? Which would you do and why?