@Aaron Lietz - Your post caught my attention, as someone who has taught college architecture, had two mentors, and has coached/mentor real estate in the past. As in the collegiate arena, or for the most part in life, the 80/20 rule applies. While teaching, 90% of the students would say their goal was an A. The 10% who stated their objective was to learn "x" or "y" were usually the 10% who earned an A, the rest did not put in the effort to earn an A.
There are truths to your points 1, 2, and 3. As I have never been in the music industry or considered being a mentor a full time job, I can not comment on 4-7 as an industry. I did disclose the challenges as well as strategies to overcome the challenges, nor will I state I had an answer for every challenge. I do agree whole selling is a hard way to earn a living.
I also do believe their are other tangible benefits for working in real estate that you did not disclose in your analysis. But at that point, it appears your discussion was more about whole selling versus the pros and cons of a having a mentor.
When asked if someone should have a mentor, I will most likely say yes - because I have benefited from them. I will also state, going into the relationship, one should have a clear goal and expectation - what they are trying to accomplish, and how much time and energy are they willing to accomplish said goal. Otherwise, the 80/20 rule will prevail.
Is your post about mentors or about whole selling? I agree it is a tough business, much like being a real estate broker. That being said, a tool we have used and an important one to have in the tool belt. It is also important as a buyer to understand the role of a whole seller. I would also contend, not everyone has the ability to make $250,000 - $350,000 in a corporate job, so I tip my hat to you for accomplishing that. By the government's definition, that puts you in the top 1%. I do know whole sellers who are also in the top 1%. So, by the government's standard it is equally as hard to earn the same amout of money. If you determine it is easier for you to do that working a corporate job, awesome - I trust it serves the country as a whole for you to be doing your job well. If someone else finds more satisfaction being a whole seller, more power to them - not a job I desire to do full time. If someone wants to coach full time, I hope they are good at what they sell, and help those who buy from them.