Well, it turns out we won't be able to reuse the laminate flooring as we'd hoped. So, the replacement is going to add a few thousand dollars to the budget. To make up for this cost, we have chosen to sacrafice the jack-and-jill master bathroom. Part of our bathroom rehab included cutting into the closet in a second bedroom, moving the sink and vanity, and installing a door between the biggest bedroom and the bathroom. It is a shared bathroom with the other two bedrooms upstairs, so it wasn't a true master. Ultimately, we didn't think the $1,800 was worth it given the additional cost of installing the laminate flooring downstairs.
We've also decided to go with granite countertops and a mosaic tile backsplash in the kitchen. That too has add a few thousand dollars to the budget.
Our contingency fund was still pretty full though with only a sump pump failure (that caused no damage, just some pooling of water in an unfinished part of the basement) and gas leak due to a leaky valve having tapped the fund thus far.
We saved about $600 on our appliances by buying them on black Friday (online), so that helps cover the cost overruns as well. All told, we're expecting to be in for about $52,000 on the rehab. That will bring our total all-in cost to about $137,000 excluding loan costs on the back-end. We now expect the property to appraise at the higher-end of the range based on a recent sale two blocks away with similar finishes and only 1.5 as opposed to 2 bathrooms. Should still be a good deal for us.