This is my fourth property. A vacation rental on a small all sports lake. The property was listed at 2,832 square feet. Inspections turned up a couple small issues that were fixed. However, when the appraisal happened the appraiser found only 2,132 square feet. We looked into this to verify square footage, which we admittedly should have done earlier, and found out the website the listing agent used was incorrect and the property is in fact 2,132 square feet.
I put it under contract at 370k, the appraisal came back at 370k. I know that technically the value is the value but I can't help but feel jibbed as I thought I was getting the property around 130 a square foot and truthfully I am paying around 170 a square foot. A house two doors down that was used as a comp in the appraisal, and is not as nice sold for 174 a square foot in January.
All I have to do is continue on and the house will be mine, and I think would be a nice short term rental. I guess I don't know why I'm having such a hard time accepting this. I am feeling a little childish- as if I'm mad I didn't get a "better deal"
I genuinely need some advice as I have been going back and forth for three days driving my wife crazy. We are told, of course, there is a backup offer ready to go. I feel like any request for concession is going to be combated by the fact that the house appraised at 370k regardless of square footage.
Thank you for reading this, and I really look forward to hearing what you guys have to say.
Thanks,
Sam